The series had its origins in the 1982
CBS sitcom pilot
Cass Malloy. Creators Dan Guntzelman and Steve Marshall pitched the format to CBS that later became the syndicated ''She's the Sheriff'': that of a late sheriff's wife taking over her husband's job, and the challenges she faced as a woman in a male-oriented environment.
Annie Potts was originally cast as the titular Cass Malloy, but she was soon dropped during development in favor of
Caroline McWilliams, who was in search of a starring vehicle after leaving the hit
ABC series
Benson. The pilot was shot and greenlighted by CBS, and aired as a one-off on July 21, 1982. The pilot did not perform to CBS's expectations, and thus was not picked up as a series. George Wyner and Lou Richards appeared in both
Cass Malloy and ''She's the Sheriff'', but in the CBS pilot, their characters' surnames were different. Wyner played Deputy Max Rosenkrantz, who had hoped to fill the shoes of deceased sheriff Big Jim Malloy, but who was now upset about being passed over in favor of Malloy's wife. Richards played Deputy Dennis Little in the pilot. The cast also featured
Glynn Turman as officer Woodrow Freeman, a character that served as the basis for Leonard Lightfoot's Alvin Wiggins in ''She's the Sheriff
; Dick Butkus as officer Alvin Dimsky; Murphy Dunne as Adam Barrett; and Dianne Kay (in her first project after Eight is Enough'') as Tina Marie Nelson. Sheriff Cass Malloy had three children in the original pilot: teenager Colleen (
Amanda Wyss), preteen Nona (Heather Hobbs) and the youngest, "Little Big" Jim (
Corey Feldman). While ''She's the Sheriff
was set in Lakes County, Nevada, Cass Malloy'' was situated in Burr County, Indiana. Guntzelman and Marshall would find success as producers a few years later with
ABC's
Growing Pains, which prompted them to revisit the
Cass Malloy teleplay in hopes of finally getting it on the air as a series.
Lorimar-Telepictures took an interest in a revised version of the script and greenlighted a series order in 1987 for the then-burgeoning first-run syndication market. Early in production, a two-page ad was placed in the January 5, 1987, issue of
Broadcasting & Cable magazine listing the show under the working title
Suddenly Sheriff and with
Priscilla Barnes as the star (Barnes had been the second replacement for Suzanne Somers on ''Three's Company''.) It is not known exactly when the show's name and casting were finalized. ==Production==