Original production Side Show opened on
Broadway on October 16, 1997 at the
Richard Rodgers Theatre.
Robert Longbottom directed and choreographed, the sets were by
Robin Wagner, costumes by
Gregg Barnes and lighting by
Brian MacDevitt. The cast starred Emily Skinner as Daisy Hilton and Alice Ripley as Violet Hilton. Also featured was
J. Robert Spencer. Despite receiving some positive reviews, the show closed on January 3, 1998 after 31 previews and 91 regular performances. Original producers were
Manny Azenberg and former actor
Wayne Rogers. The show was nominated for four
Tony Awards in 1998 at the
52nd Tony Awards.
Regional theatre productions In 1998,
TheatreWorks near
San Francisco produced the regional premiere of
Side Show at the
Mountain View Center for the Performing Arts. The production was a critical and popular success, receiving a
Garland Award (
Los Angeles) and various Dean Goodman Critics Choice Awards (San Francisco). The production was directed by Robert Kelley and Bick Goss (Goss also choreographed). Kristin Behrendt, who had been a standby for (and performed) the role of Violet in the original Broadway cast, played the role of Daisy. The cast also included Debra Wiseman (
Bullets Over Broadway, The Scarlet Pimpernel) as Violet, AJ Vincent (
The Will Rogers Follies) as Terry (Dean Goodman Critics Choice Award Best Actor in a Musical), Pierce Peter Brandt (
Les Miserables, Martin Guerre) as Buddy, and Stephonne Smith (
The Scarlet Pimpernel) as Jake. In 2001,
Signature Theatre Company's production starred Amy Goldberger (Daisy), Sherri Edelen (Violet), Will Gartshore (Buddy Foster), Matt Bogart (Terry Connor), Eric Jordan Young (Jake), and Michael Sharp (The Boss). An abridged version of
Side Show was presented at the
Kennedy Center in
Washington, D.C. October 2–5, 2008 as part of their
Broadway: Three Generations production.
Jenn Colella and
Lisa Brescia played Daisy and Violet, respectively,
Bobby Steggert played Buddy, and
Max von Essen played Terry.
Revised version; Broadway revival A revised version of the musical ran at the
La Jolla Playhouse in La Jolla, California, in late 2013.
Bill Condon directed, with
Erin Davie as Violet and
Emily Padgett as Daisy. The show had a "darker approach" and "incorporates new songs as well as additional biographical details of the Hilton twins' life and historical figures of the era." Several new songs were added. In Act 1, Terry sings "Very Well Connected" to try to convince the twins that he can get them booked on the Orpheum Circuit. Buddy teaches the girls a song called "Typical Girls Next Door". During a backstory flashback, British physicians sing "Cut Them Apart" while the girls sing "I Will Never Leave You" for the first time.
Harry Houdini (Javier Ignacio) teaches the girls to tune out all distractions around them in order to get some private time ("All in the Mind"). When the girls are being brought to the US, Sir sings "Come See a New Land" ("Come Look at the Freaks" reworked). The twins' first big performance is a new song, "Ready to Play." Act 2 opens with a new number, "Stuck With You", featuring the twins, Buddy, and a boy with whom Buddy seems to be having a relationship. This is followed by "Leave Me Alone", moved to Act 2. "New Year's Day" was reworked and added to "New Year's Eve". "Tunnel of Love" was reworked as "A Great Wedding Show." Several other songs from the original were cut: "You Deserve a Better Life", "Crazy, Deaf and Blind", "More Than We Bargained For", "When I'm By Your Side", "Overnight Sensation", "We Share Everything", "Rare Songbirds on Display", and "Beautiful Day for a Wedding". The production next played at the Kennedy Center in June and July 2014. with choreography by
Anthony Van Laast, scenic design by
David Rockwell, costumes by
Paul Tazewell, lighting by
Jules Fisher and
Peggy Eisenhauer and sound by
Kai Harada. The cast starred Davie and Padgett and also featured Matthew Hydzik as Buddy Foster,
Robert Joy as Sir, Ryan Silverman as Terry Connor and David St. Louis as Jake. The production began previews on Broadway at the
St. James Theatre on October 28, 2014, opening officially on November 17, with the same cast. Despite very positive reviews, the revival did not catch on with audiences and closed on January 4, 2015 after only seven weeks.
London The musical made its UK premiere in 2016 at the
Southwark Playhouse in
London for a limited run, running from October 21, 2016 to December 3, 2016. Directed by Hannah Chissick, the cast featured
Louise Dearman (Daisy) and
Laura Pitt-Pulford (Violet), with Dominic Hodson as Buddy Foster. On March 3rd 2024, a concert production was staged at
The London Palladium, starring
Louise Dearman (Daisy) and
Rachel Tucker (Violet). The cast also featured
Bradley Jaden as Terry and Tosh Wanogho-Maud as Buddy. Adapted from the 2014 Broadway production, an edited book was presented with newly written narration to accompany the score, which was presented intact.
University Productions The first collegiate production of the reworked version of
Side Show was directed by VP Boyle and produced as an immersive theatrical experience by
USC School of Dramatic Arts in October, 2016 and featured real twins. Daisy was played by Selene Julia Klasner and Violet by Carson Klasner. ==Awards and nominations==