U.S. senator
On September 25, 1946, Governor Caldwell appointed Holland to fill the U.S. Senate vacancy created by the death of
Charles O. Andrews a week earlier. In November, Holland defeated Republican J. Harry Schad to win a full six-year term. Holland, like many
Southern Democrats, was a conservative who was pro-business, supported racial segregation, staunchly opposed the
civil rights movement and
labor unions, and believed in a limited federal government and states' rights. He opposed
Harry Truman's proposals for
national health insurance and the
Fair Employment Practices Commission, and voted to override Truman's veto of the
Taft-Hartley Act. Holland's views contrasted with those of Claude Pepper, the senior U.S. senator from Florida during his first four years, who was a more outspoken liberal.
First term As he had in the Florida Senate, Holland supported abolishing the poll tax for federal elections during his time in the U.S. Senate, making an attempt to ban it during every session for a dozen years after arriving in Congress. During the
80th Congress, allies in the
U.S. House of Representatives introduced H.R. 29, which passed the House on a 290-112 vote on July 21, 1947, but was
filibustered in the Senate. During the following 81st Congress, H.R. 3199 was introduced; it passed the House on July 26, 1949, on a 273-116 vote, but failed to get past the
Senate Committee on Rules and Administration. On other issues, Holland remained a
segregationist who supported discrimination against Black voters, but maintained his view that the poll tax should be repealed because it was a form of wealth discrimination. He, along with all other senators from the former
Confederate states (except
Lyndon B. Johnson,
Estes Kefauver, and
Albert Gore, Sr.), signed the 1956 "
Southern Manifesto", which condemned the Supreme Court ruling in
Brown v. Board of Education (1954), declaring that segregation of public schools was unconstitutional, and promised to resist its implementation. Holland did favor statehood for
Alaska and
Hawaii. The first Southerner to support statehood for Hawaii, and the
Hawaii Admission Act. Along with his support for Alaska's statehood, he introduced the two senators-elect from Alaska who were produced as a result of the
Alaska-Tennessee Plan to the U.S. Senate:
E.L. "Bob" Bartlett and
Ernest Gruening.
Third term Up for re-election in
1958, Holland was challenged by his former colleague Claude Pepper (who had been defeated for renomination in 1950) in the Democratic primary. After fending off Pepper's challenge, he easily defeated his Republican opponent, Leland Hyzer, in November to win a third term. During the
87th Congress, Holland finally succeeded in his long-standing quest to ban the poll tax federally. Holland introduced a
constitutional amendment that would prohibit states from conditioning the right to vote in
federal elections on payment of a
poll tax or other types of tax. The amendment was approved by a required two-thirds vote of both houses of Congress in August 1962 and was quickly
ratified by the required three-fourths of the states (38), and in January 1964 became the
Twenty-fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution. Described as a conservative Democrat, Holland believed in maintaining the filibuster and believed that civil rights was a matter for the states. Speaking in opposition to the
Civil Rights Act of 1964, Holland said "We'll stand up and fight as long as we can".
Fourth term Holland won a fourth term in
1964, this time defeating Republican
Claude R. Kirk, Jr. (who would be elected governor in 1966). In November 1969, at the age of 77, Holland announced that he would not seek re-election in
1970. He actively campaigned for Democrat
Lawton Chiles, who defeated Republican U.S. representative
William C. Cramer in the general election. Cramer had the endorsement of President
Richard Nixon, and had handily defeated
G. Harrold Carswell (whom Nixon had earlier nominated unsuccessfully to the
U.S. Supreme Court) in the Republican primary. ==Personal life==