The parish was established from
St Alban's Church, Warrington by the Benedictine priests from
Ampleforth Abbey who served there. Fr. John Placid Hall
OSB is credited with conceiving the idea to build the church and to have chosen the site. The site had been occupied by a cotton mill. The site was bought on 5 May 1870 for £4,000. The church was designed by
E. W. Pugin and its construction started in 1875, just before Pugin's death. The foundation stone was laid by Bishop O'Reilly of Liverpool on Sunday 9 May 1875. It was completed by
Peter Paul Pugin in 1877. The architectural historian
Nikolaus Pevsner considered it to be one of their best churches. The church was opened on Thursday 30 August 1877. The splendid reredos and rose window were blessed on 1 November 1885. The very tall and slender southwest tower, a departure from the original design, was designed by Pugin & Pugin and built by Travis & Wevill of Liverpool in 1907. A northeast chapel, the First World War Memorial Chapel, designed by
Frederick Walters was added in 1923. Fr. Paul William Wright
OSB announced on Sunday 15 January 2012 that
Ampleforth Abbey could no longer provide a priest for the parish due to a lack of manpower and that he would be the last monk-priest to serve in the parish. Thus ending a
Benedictine presence in
Warrington lasting 250 years. Fr. William Wright's last Mass was on Sunday 9 September 2012. Discussions about the
Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter taking over the parish were held in 2012, but were inconclusive. The Archdiocese of Liverpool then took over the pastoral care of the people of the parish. The pastoral needs of the congregation were then met by Monsignor John Devine
OBE, of
St Benedict's Church, Warrington, who was later given charge of the parish of
St Oswald's Church, Padgate as well. On Saturday 4 July 2015, the
Archbishop of Liverpool,
Malcolm McMahon,
OP announced: "I have invited the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter to come to the Archdiocese and to have responsibility for St Mary’s Church, Warrington. In due course this will become a centre for the celebration of the extraordinary form of the Roman Rite and the sacraments. The priests of this fraternity will not, however, assume pastoral responsibility for St Mary’s parish, which will be the responsibility of Fr David Heywood from September." The first public Mass by the FSSP in the church was celebrated by Fr Armand de Malleray on Sunday 15 November 2015. The formal Inaugural Mass, attended by the Archbishop of Liverpool
Malcolm McMahon and Abbot Cuthbert Madden
OSB of
Ampleforth Abbey was held on 21 November 2015." For the first time in many decades, priestly ordinations in the traditional rite were conducted at St Mary's on 17 June 2017. Deacons Alex Stewart and Krzysztof Sanetra
FSSP were ordained to the
priesthood by Archbishop McMahon. Following the transition to the FSSP, the church is not technically a parish church, but a shrine within a parish, as the parish itself was merged with two others,
St Benedict's Church, Warrington,
St Oswald's Church, Padgate. In late April 2018, it was announced that the new name for the merged parish is Blessed
James Bell Parish. ==Architecture==