Fans began to speculate on social media about possible people who inspired the show's fictional characters. In April 2024 Gadd asked fans to cease speculating. After being falsely identified online as the factual person from whom the character Darrien was derived, the theatre director
Sean Foley reported the false allegations to the police. The police investigated the reports. Earlier
tweets from a
Twitter account linked to Muir-Harvey resulted in increased fan connections between her and the Martha character. These included a reference to hanging curtains, a sexually suggestive phrase that was later used in the script of
Baby Reindeer. During her
Uncensored interview, Muir-Harvey said that she had met Gadd several times at
The Hawley Arms, Camden, but denied sending him 41,000 emails or going to his home, as was stated of her erstwhile character on the show. She said that she was planning to start legal action for defamation against both Gadd and Netflix for claiming the series is "a true story" and suggesting that she had been convicted of stalking and sexual assault, as is the Martha character in the series. Muir-Harvey said she had sent up to 10 emails and a letter, as well as several tweets, to Gadd. She later claimed she was paid £250 to appear, and said that the interview left her feeling "a bit used". The interview drew some criticism, with people questioning the ethics of the event. Laura Wray, a lawyer and widow of the Scottish politician
Jimmy Wray, said that she had briefly employed Muir-Harvey at her law firm in 1997. After Muir-Harvey was dismissed, she engaged in stalker-like behaviour towards Wray, forcing her to take out an injunction. On 6 June 2024 Muir-Harvey filed a lawsuit against Netflix in the United States, alleging defamation, negligence, and
gross negligence, seeking $170 million in damages and claiming that the show "viciously destroyed" her. Netflix responded that viewers were unlikely to associate the character with Muir-Harvey. On 27 September US judge
R. Gary Klausner dismissed Muir-Harvey's negligence and gross negligence claims, along with her request for punitive damages, but allowed her to continue the
defamation case against Netflix. Klausner noted that the series begins by stating that "this is a true story", differentiating it from Gadd's play, which was said to be "based on a true story". A federal judge set a date for court proceedings to begin on 6 May 2025 at the
Central District of California court, but this was halted by an appeal lodged by Netflix at the
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. ==Notes==