On November 28, 1963, Kupcinet had dinner with actor
Mark Goddard and his wife, Marcia Rogers Goddard, at their home in
Beverly Hills, California. Although expected at 6:30 p.m., she arrived by taxicab about an hour late. The Goddards later reported that she scarcely ate and appeared physically unsettled, noting "her lips seemed numb. Her voice was funny. She moved her head at odd angles" and that her pupils were
constricted. When Mark confronted Kupcinet about her behavior, she began to cry and put her arm around him. At one point during the meal, she told an unsubstantiated story about a baby that had been abandoned on her doorstep earlier that day. After returning to her apartment, Kupcinet was visited by writer Edward Stephen Rubin, and later by actor Robert Hathaway. According to their statements to authorities, the three watched television and had coffee until Kupcinet fell asleep on the couch. She later went to her bedroom, and Rubin and Hathaway departed around 11:15 p.m., locking the door behind them. Hathaway stated that he returned home and was later joined by Andrew Prine, and the two spent several hours talking and watching television. When Kupcinet did not telephone them as she had said she would, the Goddards went to her apartment on November 30. Detectives concluded that the story Kupcinet had told regarding an abandoned baby on her doorstep was unfounded.
Theories Irv Kupcinet opinion on Karyn's death Andrew Prine told investigators that he had spoken with Kupcinet by telephone on the day before she died. Law enforcement also questioned members of the Hollywood community, including Edward Stephen Rubin and Robert Hathaway, who were believed to have been among the last to see her. Both men were considered possible suspects during the investigation. In his 1988 memoir, Irv Kupcinet wrote that he and his wife did not believe Prine was involved in their daughter’s death. He indicated that they instead regarded another acquaintance, actor and producer David Lange, as a potential suspect, citing information they had been given during the investigation. The case remains officially unsolved. Later in the 1960s, David Lange moved from Los Angeles to New York. The next public display of his name occurred in 1971 when the movie
Klute, a box office success, listed him in the credits as “co-producer.” The screenplay, written by
Andy Lewis and his brother Dave Lewis, was filmed entirely on location in New York City in 1970. It is about an aspiring stage actress who has turned to prostitution to pay the rent in a brownstone on Manhattan’s West 43rd Street, and she is repeatedly harassed by telephone and stalked by a man whom she met once a long time ago.
Alleged connection to JFK Kupcinet’s death was first referenced in connection with the
assassination of John F. Kennedy in 1967 by
Penn Jones Jr. in his self-published book
Forgive My Grief II. Jones cited an
Associated Press report concerning an unidentified woman who placed a telephone call in or near
Oxnard, California approximately twenty minutes before the assassination. Jones alleged that the caller was Kupcinet. He claimed she had been attempting to warn a local telephone operator of the impending shooting after learning about it in advance. According to the Associated Press, the woman could not be identified. According to Penn Jones, Irv Kupcinet had purportedly received information, about a plan to assassinate the president, from
Jack Ruby, whom Jones speculated may have known Irv in Chicago in the 1940s. Jones theorized that Karyn Kupcinet was killed by individuals associated with the
American Mafia as a warning to her father to remain silent about why Kennedy and his accused assassin
Lee Harvey Oswald had been killed. Irv Kupcinet denied that either he or his daughter had foreknowledge of the shootings of Kennedy or Oswald. Friends who were with Karyn in
Palm Springs, California on November 22, 23 and 24, 1963, including Andrew Prine and
Earl Holliman, reported that she reacted to news coverage with shock and grief and that she did not indicate prior knowledge of the events or previous familiarity with Jack Ruby. For the
Ventura County Star, the story was local, as employees of
GTE, a telephone service provider, had been able, in 1963, to narrow down the origin of the phone call to Oxnard. Citing Federal Bureau of Investigation records declassified years after the assassination, the article reported that two GTE telephone operators who heard the call told the FBI the caller’s voice did not match Kupcinet’s in age or tone, and that they believed the caller may have been "mentally disturbed". Although Irv Kupcinet was socially acquainted with several prominent
Chicago Outfit figures, including
Sam Giancana and
Tony Accardo, he rejected claims linking his associates to his daughter’s death. Following her death, Kupcinet sought the assistance of attorney and Mafia
fixer Sidney Korshak to secure the release of his daughter’s remains. These associations later contributed to continued public speculation, which Kupcinet consistently disputed. Irv Kupcinet received a letter of condolence from
Rose Kennedy following his daughter’s death. No official investigation has established a connection between the Kennedy assassination and the death of Karyn Kupcinet.
Media attention In the early 1990s, during renewed public interest in the Kennedy assassination around the release of the film
JFK, Irv Kupcinet publicly criticized conspiracy theories related to the assassination. ==Legacy==