On July 15, 2013, Sotloff arrived in Israel for his former roommate Benny Scholder's wedding and wanted to spend a couple of weeks there. Before his kidnapping, he was in
Kilis, a town at the border of Turkey and Syria. During a talk with
Ben Taub, a journalist and philosophy student at
Princeton University, he confessed to being tired of the Middle East, that he was "sick of being beaten up, and shot at, and accused of being a spy." His intention was to stop reporting and come back to the United States, but he wanted one more tour of Syria first. According to Taub's statement, it is likely that Sotloff was betrayed to jihadis by his
fixer. Sotloff was kidnapped along with his fixer and the fixer's brother and cousins on August 4, 2013, near
Aleppo after crossing the Syrian border from Turkey. The fixer and his family members were released 15 days later. He was thought to have been held in
Raqqa. Sotloff fasted secretly during the Jewish fast day of
Yom Kippur in September 2013 during his captivity, by feigning illness. Before his execution he criticized the foreign policy of Barack Obama for non-fulfillment of his pre-election promise to bring all American soldiers back home. His family kept the news of his kidnapping secret, fearing he would be harmed if they went public. His family and government agencies worked privately to gain his release for a year. Sotloff, his family, friends, and previous employers such as
The Jerusalem Post went to great lengths to keep his
Jewish background and
Israeli citizenship a secret from his
ISIL captors after Sotloff was shown in the
beheading video of
James Foley. It is unknown if those attempts had any effect, since the information was online for the duration of his captivity. Following Sotloff's death in September, ISIS published 11 rules that pertained to journalists "who wish to continue working in the governorate." The first rule stated that all journalists must swear their allegiance as subjects of the Islamic State. On August 19, 2014, the terrorist organization
The Islamic State (IS) released a video titled "
A Message to America," which showed the beheading of fellow journalist
James Foley. At the end of the video, ISIS threatened
President of the United States Barack Obama, telling him that "his next move" would decide the fate of Sotloff. Only days after this threat was released, the U.S. stepped up airstrikes against IS, firing 14 missiles at various ISIS
Humvees near the
Mosul Dam. Shortly after the release of the video, a petition was started on
whitehouse.gov, which called for President Obama to save Sotloff's life. The petition attracted thousands of signatures within days. On August 27, 2014, Sotloff's mother released a short video asking Islamic State leader
Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi to release her son. On September 2, 2014, the
SITE Intelligence Group discovered the video of Sotloff's killing, titled "
A Second Message to America" and released by
Al-Furqan Media Productions, on what they called "a file-sharing site" and released it to their subscribers. == Tributes ==