Stroll On was met with widespread critical acclaim in the UK. In
The Daily Telegraph, Maurice Rosenbaum declared: “Ashley’s own songs are the product of an extraordinary gift for creating material of true folk quality” and, in
Melody Maker,
Karl Dallas hailed it as “the finest album since folk became contemporary”. At the end of 1974 it was awarded “Contemporary Folk album of the Year” in the leading monthly folk magazine,
Folk Review. Music journalist
Colin Harper described it as "a masterful, beautifully textured and gentle epic" and "a masterpiece of its kind – a beautiful, rich and deeply atmospheric collection of very English songs, like a musical impression of Dickens, Victorian Christmas cards and Thomas Hardy’s Wessex with a running concept concerning seasonal change". The June 1999 issue of
Mojo magazine featured the original
Stroll On in its regular full-page series "Buried Treasure". Lee Blackstone, writing in
RootsWorld, said: "
Stroll On: Revisited is a classic album in every sense. The musical guests run the gamut of the English folk-rock scene, but, mind you, this isn't a case of spoiled broth. Rather,
Stroll On manages to be a well-orchestrated calendar album, with the play of seasons the overarching theme... Incredibly, the entire album has worn remarkably well and it bears the stamp of timelessness that the best British folk-rock can conjure... As a debut album,
Stroll On is remarkably mature, and Ashley's magical achievement can now be savored again." Keith Hadad, reviewing the album on Record Crates United, said: "[T]he range of influences on Stroll On is daringly unique. British and American folk and rock traditions have been seamlessly blended in with elements of Irish and classical music as well... Ashley’s starkly echoing vocals [on "Springsong"] sometimes harken back to Celtic choral singing while Kirby’s string arrangement is reminiscent of the Pastoral composers, like Ralph Vaughan Williams. Meanwhile the only percussion present in the song is a tabla being played in the traditional Hindustani style... [it] works beautifully here, making this an absolute highlight of the record." Alan Rose, for
The Living Tradition magazine, said: "'Stroll On' was released in 1974 amid critical acclaim, which all these years later seems eminently justified. The very first track led to his alternative title of 'The Fire and Wine Guy', and after twenty-five years its lush harmonies, electric arrangement and sound philosophy ensure that its magic is undiminished... Ashley's songs are packed with life-affirming, earth-touching sentiments, deceptively simple at first hearing but unfolding at each repeat to display deeper meanings with staggeringly intelligent and original use of language." ==Track listing==