Carnival of Souls had its world premiere at the Granada Theatre in Lawrence, Kansas, on September 26, 1962. While the US release of
Carnival of Souls failed to include a copyright on the prints, automatically placing them in the public domain, the foreign release marketed by Walter Manley did contain a copyright card and was protected for overseas sales. The 35 mm theatrical prints were cut by Herz-Lion to 78 minutes, which trimmed the camera original. However, the 16 mm television copies were printed complete and individually cut by each station to fit their time slot, which is why they vary in length.
WOR-TV in New York City used to broadcast the film intact in a late-night time slot in the 1960s. The scenes cut by the theatrical distributor include a scene where Mary stops at a gas station and discusses the carnival building with the attendant, a longer dialogue sequence between the organ factory boss and a carpenter, and an extra scene where the doctor talks to the landlady. In 1989, the film was screened at festivals across Europe and the United States, affording it renewed public interest, and it has subsequently appeared at numerous Halloween film festivals. Prints of
Carnival of Souls vary in length, from 78 minutes in the theatrical release to 84 minutes in the original cut. While some sources have erroneously listed the film at a 91-minute-runtime, Michael Weldon stated in
The Psychotronic Video Guide to Film that the original theatrical cut of the film ran approximately 80 minutes. He also stated that the director's cut, which runs 84 minutes, is "the best and most complete version we'll ever see."
Reception and legacy Carnival of Souls went largely unnoticed by critics upon its initial release and received "delayed acclaim" in the ensuing decades,
Leonard Maltin gave
Carnival of Souls a score of two-and-a-half out of four stars, calling the film an "eerie" and "imaginative low budget effort." Critic
Roger Ebert likened the film to a "lost episode of
The Twilight Zone," and noted that it possessed an "intriguing power." Joe Brown of
The Washington Post remarked upon the film's cinematography, writing: "Harvey's camerawork gives a new twist to the word 'deadpan,' making the most mundane places and people imaginable seem like ghastly hallucinations, and the director shows a flair for elegantly employing existing locations and lighting for maximum disorientation value."
Stephen Holden of
The New York Times saw the 1989 screening at the Fantasy Festival and wrote: "What has earned
Carnival of Souls its reputation is the director's knack for building a mood of fatalistic angst." The
Los Angeles Times Peter Rainer perceived the film's cinematography to be inconsistent in merit, called the acting "fairly amateurish" with "a one-take-only quality", and noted the "inept
post-dubbing"; however, he concluded that "these rinky-dink elements only add to the horror."
TV Guide gave
Carnival of Souls a score of three stars out of four, praising the film's atmosphere, acting, and eerie score, calling it, "A chilling ghost story with artistic pretensions."
Film Reel.com gave
Carnival of Souls a positive review, praising the film's atmosphere, slow-building tension, and disturbing visuals. On
Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an approval rating of 87% based on , with a rating average of 7.2/10. The site's consensus states that the film "offers delightfully chilling proof that when it comes to telling an effective horror story, less can often be much, much more".
Carnival of Souls has gradually developed a
cult following since its release and is now considered a low-budget classic.
Slant Magazine placed the film at number 32 on its "100 Best Horror Movies of All Time".
Paste magazine ranked the film at number 85 on its list of "100 Best Horror Movies of All Time".
Rights Although some believe that
Carnival of Souls is in the public domain, the original filmmakers received official copyright status on the film in 1987 in the names of Harold Harvey and John W. Clifford. This was done under copyright registration number PAO1-230-677, in the Office of the United States Register of Copyrights in Washington, D.C. John W. Clifford also has a copyright on his original unpublished screenplay manuscript (copyright # PAU2-064-013). Clifford and Harvey were legally able to copyright their film because the original distributor, Harcourt Productions, never filed for copyright in 1962. The film, including the original negative and a handful of surviving prints and outtakes, were purchased from the filmmakers, along with all rights, by Peter Soby and Matthew Irvine of Chicago West Entertainment in January 1997.
Home media Carnival of Souls has been released in a significant number of formats through numerous distributors, which, according to film scholars Chris Vander Kaay and Kathleen Fernandez-Vander Kaay, has ensured it "a constant presence in the video market and [contributed to] its enduring cult popularity."
The Criterion Collection licensed the official copyright version of the film from Peter Soby and Matthew Irvine and issued a 2-disc
DVD set of the film in 2000, featuring both a 78-minute theatrical version and an extended 84-minute director's cut. In 2009,
Legend Films released the film on DVD featuring both the black-and-white and a
colorized version of the directors cut, including an
audio commentary track by comedian
Michael J. Nelson, a former writer and host of
Mystery Science Theater 3000. In 2016, the Criterion Collection reissued the film on DVD, as well as premiering it on
Blu-ray, featuring a new restoration. In 2012, the
Academy Film Archive restored
Carnival of Souls alongside Peter Soby and Matthew Irvine. They also keep the original negatives stored in their facilities. The film has been named as a precursor to the works of various filmmakers, including
David Lynch,
George A. Romero,
Lucrecia Martel and
James Wan. The film was used for a
RiffTrax Live event in October 2016, where former
Mystery Science Theater 3000 cast members
Bill Corbett,
Kevin Murphy and
Michael J. Nelson riffed the film for a live audience and broadcast to other theaters through
NCM Fathom. Rifftrax's website offers the video downloads of the live performance as well as a studio-recorded riff of the film. A novelization of the film titled
Nightmare Pavilion, written by Andrew J. Rausch, was released by Happy Cloud Media in October 2020.
Carnival of Souls (1998) Producer Peter Soby negotiated the rights to the title from Herk Harvey and John Clifford, resulting in the 1998 version of
Carnival of Souls (also known as
Wes Craven Presents Carnival of Souls). Not a remake, it shares little in common with the original film, apart from a similar ending. Sidney Berger, who appears in the original film as John Linden, appears in a cameo in the later film. ==See also==