Original release The compilation received critical acclaim. Critics were disappointed by the unaltered rerelease, which they found lazy. They expressed surprise the developers did not take advantage of the extra space Wii discs offer to add more games or use the
Super Mario All-Stars + Super Mario World version.
The A.V. Club said the level design documents were "obscured by pictures, and schematics written in Japanese with no translation". Meanwhile,
IGN opined the booklet failed to demonstrate Mario's importance, missing information about the Game Boy installments, ''Yoshi's Island
, and other Nintendo games. Others found the booklet interesting; GamesRadar+ stated that for Mario'' fans Miyamoto's original outline "alone is worth $30". The soundtrack CD received criticism and was viewed as a missed opportunity. Reviewers were disappointed it contained only ten tracks and that half of it was dedicated to sound effects. For instance,
Nintendo Life said it "doesn't even fill half of that potential running time" of 74 minutes of CD audio. Similarly,
IGN said ten tracks were not enough, including only one of the twenty tracks from
Super Mario Galaxy (2007). Conversely,
The Guardian said the CD would make players happy and
GamesRadar+ thought it was rare for Nintendo to release game soundtracks outside Japan.
GamesRadar+ said the CD helped make the compilation seem important, noting that it contained the first official release of the
Super Mario Bros. "
Ground Theme".
Nintendo Life wrote there was no reason for Nintendo not to add more to the compilation, suggesting it would not have taken much effort to add interviews, advertisements, and other behind-the-scenes content. Despite the general disappointment, critics said the games remained high quality. Some admitted to preferring the NES originals, but others thought the updated 16-bit graphics and addition of a save feature were great. However, some encouraged readers to purchase the games individually on the Wii's
Virtual Console service instead if they had not already purchased the compilation.
GamesRadar+,
IGN, and
Official Nintendo Magazine noted this was a cheaper way to experience them. As
Nintendo World Report wrote, "in the end, the value of [
Super Mario All-Stars] lies in whether you want to invest once more in these classic
Mario titles." == Legacy ==