Surahs in the
Qur'an are not arranged in the
chronological order of revelation because order of
wahy or
chronological order of revelation is not a part of Quran but according to Aisha: "Muhammed always recited the Quran in Chronological order even in prayer" and there are many verses on arrangement of Quran e.g. Surah Furqhan Verse 32 "...we have repeated it in perfect arrangement". Also other imaams tell that Ali was ordered by Muhammed to arrange the Quran in Chronological Order. According to Israr Ahmed: Muhammed told his followers the placement (
sahaba) in Quranic order of every
Wahy revealed along with the original text of Quran, Israr Ahmed's word on this cannot be taken as the only truth or the only view on this subject.
Wm Theodore de Bary, an
East Asian studies expert, describes that "The final process of collection and codification of the Quran text was guided by one over-arching principle: God's words must not in any way be distorted or sullied by human intervention. For this reason, no serious attempt, apparently, was made to edit the numerous revelations, organize them into thematic units, or present them in chronological order....".
Surat Al-Qalam is a
Meccan sura and meccan suras are chronologically earlier
suras that were revealed to
Muhammad at
Mecca before the
hijrah to
Medina in 622
CE. They are typically shorter, with relatively short
ayat, and mostly come near the end of the Qur'an's 114 surahs. Most of the surahs containing ''
muqatta'at'' are Meccan. Henceforth apart from traditions, this surah qualifies to be Meccan typically. According to some classical traditions, commentaries and
tafsirs the proposed order is 2nd in place right after
Muhammad's first revelation. The supporting argument of this surah being the second revelation is that Arabs were unaware of
angels in the time of
Jahiliyyah and news of Muhammad's first revelation made them curious about the sanity of Muhammad, thus to refute this idea God revealed the first seven ayaat of Surah Qalam. On the other hand, the latest suggested order is 18th place according to
Theodor Nöldeke and
John Medows Rodwell setting the order band from 2nd to 18th.
Sayyid Qutb (d. 1966), who was an Egyptian author,
Islamist of the
Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood, in his
Magnum opus ''
Fi Zilal al-Qur'an'' (In the shades of the Qur'an) highlights a very interesting fact that the opening and the ending of the surah tackle the same point, therefore it is not possible to identify a specific time of revelation.
George Sale estimates the revelation to be from fourth year of
Islam. The major scholars of Islam agree (
Ijma) however that this is one of the earliest surahs to be revealed at Makkah.
Muhammad Asad (2 July 1900 – 20 February 1992) a Jewish-born
Austro-Hungarian journalist, traveler, writer,
linguist, political theorist, diplomat and
Islamic scholar, said: In the
chronological order of revelation, this surah most probably occupies the third place. Some authorities – among them
Suyuti – incline to the view that it was revealed immediately after the first five verses of
surah 96 ("The Germ-Cell"); this, however, is contradicted by some of the best-authenticated traditions, according to which most of
surah 74 came second in the order of revelation (see introductory note to that surah). In any case, "The Pen" is undoubtedly one of the oldest parts of the Qur'an. —
Muhammad Asad –
The Message of The Qur'an 1980 ==Coherence with adjacent surahs==