Survivor: Panama has received mixed to positive reviews from fans and critics. The personalities of the Casaya tribe members, in particular fan-favorite
Cirie Fields, were praised. However, aside from
Terry Deitz, the members of the La Mina tribe was criticized for being perceived as less entertaining compared to their Casaya counterparts. As such, critics believe that the season is uneven due to the contrast in entertainment between the members of the two main tribes. Dalton Ross of
Entertainment Weekly ranked this season 27th out of 40 criticizing the season's final immunity challenge for being unfair to Terry Deitz which led to an "unmemorable" final two. The gameplay of winner
Aras Baskauskas received mixed to negative reception. Baskauskas placed 23rd out of the first 34 winners in a fan poll conducted by
Entertainment Weekly in 2017 and also received the fewest first-place votes out of every winner in the poll. In 2014, Joe Reid of
The Wire ranked this season 8th out of 27. In 2015, a poll by
Rob Has a Podcast ranked this season 12th out of 30 with
Rob Cesternino ranking this season 14th. This was updated in 2021 during Cesternino's podcast,
Survivor All-Time Top 40 Rankings, ranking 15th out of 40. In 2020, The "Purple Rock Podcast" ranked this season 10th out of 40 saying the "casting here is good" and the "gameplay is almost more interesting for what doesn’t happen than what does". Later that same year,
Inside Survivor ranked this season 12th out of 40 saying it is a
GREAT season that "features some of the best characters of all-time, has innovative gameplay, superb blindsides, an underdog story, and is perhaps the funniest season ever." In 2024, Nick Caruso of
TVLine ranked this season 28th out of 47. ==References==