In October 2023, Sweet Baby attracted negative attention on
Kiwi Farms, a
web forum where a user described the company's involvement with
Alan Wake 2 as "possibly one of the biggest scandals in gaming history"; similar posts were shared on sites like
4chan and the
Reddit community
r/KotakuInAction. Employees said a small degree of harassment was directed towards the company following this attention, which increased in January 2024, when a
Steam user created a curator group listing Sweet Baby's work, encouraging players to avoid the games as the studio promoted a "
woke agenda". The curator group, known as "Sweet Baby Inc detected", received increased attention in February when a Sweet Baby employee asked others to report it for violating Steam's
code of conduct. By April, the group had more than 355,000 followers and a related
Discord server had thousands of members. Both underwent purges of content in order to stay online after Steam and Discord staff contacted their moderators about potentially violating
terms of service, as much of the user-driven content bordered on hate speech. Belair said Sweet Baby did not contact Steam's owner,
Valve, regarding the group. Theories about the studio included that it was directly or indirectly controlled by investment company
BlackRock, that it forced Remedy to make
Alan Wake 2s Saga Anderson black (which game director Kyle Rowley denied), and that it was responsible for recent failures in high-profile games such as
Suicide Squad and for
recent industry layoffs. Multiple journalists described these disproven ideas as conspiracy theories; several were based on isolated statements made by Sweet Baby employees on social media or at conferences, taken out of the larger context related to their views on diversity in game narratives.
Aftermaths Nathan Grayson noted theories would likely continue spreading as long as their narrative compelled viewers and readers;
YouTube videos about the backlash collectively received millions of views. Belair responded that Sweet Baby's work was to improve narratives generally rather than being solely focused on
diversity and inclusion; she noted gamers thought the studio had simply added
pride flags to ''
Marvel's Spider-Man 2'' when it had actually provided narrative work for about three years, including several levels and character arcs. Sweet Baby's employees faced harassment and attempted
doxing in response to the backlash, with attention drawn towards the company and its employees by high-profile social media accounts including
Elon Musk,
Matt Walsh, and
Libs of TikTok. Others who faced harassment included
Kotakus reporter who first highlighted the backlash and developers who worked with or publicly supported Sweet Baby. Several journalists and
content creators compared it to
Gamergate, and
TheGamers Stacey Henley called it "the latest
dogwhistle for rejecting
progressive ideas".
The Verges Ash Parrish felt the Discord members were not attempting to "create meaningful change for their cause" but were "simply there for the vibes, rancid though they are". The studio continued to operate as normal; Bédard felt the industry had become familiar with similar controversies since Gamergate. Its partners, like
Insomniac Games, offered advice on moving past the backlash based on their own experiences with harassment, and several developers and consultants, like
Rami Ismail and
Steve Saylor, supported the studio on social media. Journalists and academics urged the studio's other partners to publicly defend it to stop false accusations and avoid complicity, and
Game Developers Bryant Francis urged Steam and Discord to clarify their policies to avoid similar incidents and further harassment. == List of games ==