Johnny Loftus of
AllMusic wrote that "with the aid of production major-leaguer Howard Benson, they've edited the slight rookie excesses of
I Brought You My Bullets You Brought Me Your Love, resulting in a rewarding, pretty damn relentless product." Andy Greenwald of
Blender noted Way's integration of elements of his life into the songs on the album and remarked that his "gulping, gasping whine turns stompers like 'I'm Not Okay (I Promise)' into after-school poetry". Ian Mathers of
Stylus Magazine felt that the album contained "twelve near-flawless songs and an interlude in thirty-nine minutes" and that "even when it lets up, [it] doesn't let up", while Kirk Miller of
Rolling Stone described it as "a hell of a good time."
IGN critic JR was more reserved in his praise, calling
Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge "a good album" that nonetheless "isn't nearly as varied or daring as it could have been". In
The Village Voice,
Robert Christgau gave it a "dud" rating. Em Casalena of
American Songwriter wrote that the album is "a golden record in emo rock history."
NME listed the album as one of "20 Emo Albums That Have Resolutely Stood the Test of Time". The album was ranked at number 260 on
Spins "The 300 Best Albums of the Past 30 Years (1985–2014)" list.
Rock Sound wrote that the album is "an era-defining release", striking "a nerve both musically and emotionally with millions around the world." Andrew Sacher of
BrooklynVegan noted that the album's tracks "are so embedded in the DNA of
pop culture that even non-MCR-fans tend to know every word." In 2016,
Rolling Stone declared
Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge the tenth greatest emo album out of 40, saying that "
Three Cheers wasn't just a concept record, it was a concept sequel, expanding the small-screen story of 2002's
I Brought You My Bullets, You Brought Me Your Love into a big-budget production, complete with ruminations on life and death ("Helena") biting kiss-offs ("I'm Not Okay") and a series of dramatic music videos that made them MTV darlings."
Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge has sold over three million units in the United States and has been certified 3× platinum by the
RIAA as of December 2017. It has also been certified quadruple platinum in Canada, Ireland, and Mexico.
Accolades == Deluxe edition reissue ==