It is estimated that 50% to 70% of dry cleaners in the US were using PCE . Alternative solvents are available, but these may require major changes in equipment, procedures, and operator training. Flammable solvents may require installation of expensive
fire-suppression systems. Because PCE has been the longtime
de facto solvent for dry cleaning, there is considerable interest in finding a "drop-in" substitute solvent which could be used with minimal changes to existing equipment and procedures. and it is thermally stable, nonflammable, recyclable, and has very low toxicity and a pleasant smell. PCE is recycled by
distillation at its boiling point (121 °C). Unlike the related dry-cleaning solvent
carbon tetrachloride, perchloroethylene is not an
ozone-depleting substance. Perchloroethylene can cause color bleeding/loss, especially at higher temperatures. In some cases it may damage special trims, buttons and beads on some garments. It is better for oil-based stains than more common water-soluble stains. It does not leave smell on dry-cleaned clothes. A dry cleaning machine running on perchloroethylene is called a "perc machine". Perchloroethylene is classified as "probably carcinogenic to humans" (Group 2A, same classification as
red meat and hot beverages) by the
International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC). There is a suspicion that it is carcinogenic to humans in long term, but the evidence is limited since most of the evaluated dry-cleaners had heavy smoking and drinking habits which are known carcinogens and were exposed to many other chemicals at the workplace. A study published in 2011 investigated cancer rates among dry cleaners exposed to perchloroethylene for many years and laundry workers who were not exposed to perchloroethylene as the
control group, based on a total of more than nine thousand people, found no difference in the cancer rates between the two groups: there was no significant increase in the incidence of esophageal, cervical, liver, kidney and bladder cancers, which were previously suspected to be caused by perchloroethylene, between the two groups. The exposure to perchloroethylene in a typical dry cleaner is considered far below the levels required to cause any risk.
Hydrocarbons Hydrocarbon mixtures have KB values between 27–45. High flash
hydrocarbons, characterized as having a
flash point higher than , are considered to be safer than traditional hydrocarbon solvents.
Decamethylcyclopentasiloxane Decamethylcyclopentasiloxane (colloquially known as "siloxane" or "liquid silicone", trademarked Siloxane D5), It is more expensive than PCE (chemical and machinery-wise) and requires a
GreenEarth licence to be used by dry-cleaners. It does not degrade in nature, it is highly toxic to the aquatic life and has higher bioaccumulative properties than perchloroethylene.
Other solvents: niche and emerging For decades, efforts have been made to replace PCE. These alternatives have not proven popular thus far: •
Glycol ethers (also called "propylene glycol ethers") are a class of organic solvents including dipropylene glycol tert-butyl ether (DPtB), dipropylene glycol n-butyl ether (DPnB), and propylene glycol t-butyl ether (PGtBE) which were introduced in the 1990s as an alternative to PCE. These solvent mixes are flammable, but are considered comparable to high-flash hydrocarbons in fire hazard. They are not considered to be carcinogenic, and have relatively benign persistence and environmental effects. This allows faster cleaning, but can damage some synthetic beads and sequins if not used correctly. Machines used with
n-propyl bromide were converted PCE machines. Converted PCE machines often had parts incompatible with nPB which lead to leaks and increased worker exposure to nPB. : Healthwise, there are reported risks associated with nPB such as permanent numbness of nerves. Environmentally, it is approved by the US EPA. It is among the more expensive solvents, but it has advantages of faster cleaning, lower temperatures, and quick drying times. In 2016, the state of Massachusetts listed the solvent as a "Higher Hazard Substance" due to increased concerns about its health and environmental effects. •
Liquid or
supercritical is a suggested alternative solvent; however, it is inferior to perchloroethylene and hydrocarbons in removing some forms of grime. Machinery for use of is expensiveup to $90,000 more than a PCE machine, making affordability difficult for small businesses. Some cleaners with these machines keep traditional machines on-site for more-heavily soiled textiles, but others find plant-derived enzymes to be equally effective and more environmentally sustainable.
Carbon dioxide is almost entirely nontoxic (but is an
asphyxiant risk in high concentrations). :
Consumer Reports rated "superior to conventional methods", but the Drycleaning and Laundry Institute commented on its "fairly low cleaning ability" in a 2007 report. is a mild solvent overall, which lowers its ability to aggressively attack stains. One deficiency with is that its
electrical conductivity is low. As mentioned in the
Mechanism section, dry cleaning utilizes both chemical and mechanical properties to remove stains. When solvent interacts with the fabric's surface, the friction dislocates dirt. At the same time, the friction also builds up an electrical charge. Fabrics are very poor conductors, but usually this build-up of
static electricity is dissipated through the solvent. This discharge does not occur in liquid carbon dioxide, and the build-up of an electrical charge on the surface of the fabric attracts the dirt back on to the surface, diminishing the cleaning efficiency. To compensate for the poor solubility and conductivity of supercritical carbon dioxide, research has focused on additives. For increased solubility,
2-propanol has shown increased cleaning effects for liquid carbon dioxide, as it increases the ability of the solvent to dissolve polar compounds.
Obsolete solvents •
Trichloroethylene (TCE) is more aggressive (KB value: 129) •
Carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) was once widely used in dry cleaning as the first chlorinated solvent, as a non-flammable alternative to highly flammable hydrocarbon solvents and it was used until the 1950s. It was one of strongest (KB value: 136) In 1986, 489 dry-cleaning facilities in the US (about 2.2% of 21,787 dry-cleaning facilities) were using CFC-113 as their main solvent. ==Solvent reprocessing==