Tea & Sympathy was awarded "Best Cover Art" and "Album of the Year" at the 2006
ARIA Music Awards; it was also nominated for "Best Blues & Roots Album" and "Highest Selling Album". "Wish You Well" won "Best Video", while "Watch Over Me" was nominated for "Single of the Year". "Wish You Well" topped the
Triple J Hottest 100, 2005, Fanning won "Best Male Artist" for his work on the album, and as part of his acceptance speech challenged fellow Australian musicians to write protest songs—something they had been criticised for a lack of by
ARIA Hall of Fame inductee
Rob Hirst.
Tea & Sympathy was nominated for the inaugural
J Award in 2005, and Fanning won "Songwriter of the Year" at the 2006
APRA Awards.
MTV Australia named
Tea & Sympathy "Album of the Year" at its 2006
Video Music Awards.
Tea & Sympathys critical reception was moderate. It was generally seen as being less entertaining than Fanning's Powderfinger work—
The Age said Powderfinger were a "rock band ingrained in the national psyche" like
Cold Chisel, but that
Tea & Sympathy showed little resemblance to Cold Chisel frontman
Jimmy Barnes's groundbreaking debut album,
Bodyswerve. Barnaby Smith of musicOMH said the album was not "a work to suggest [Fanning's] solo career might better Powderfinger". The
BBC's Jenna Bachelor wrote that the album is "pleasant enough without pulling up any trees". Despite Fanning's claims he could not write a country song, the
Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) and BBC drew comparisons to
Neil Young and
supergroup Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young. The ABC said
Tea & Sympathy resembled the band's work, "though without the hippy, drippy lyrics", Fanning's vocals drew praise; Allmusic's Andy Whitman said he was a "fine, soulful singer" whose "vocal presence alone merits attention". ==Track listing==