The Teaches of Peaches received generally favorable reviews. The album holds a score of 73 out of 100 on the review aggregator website
Metacritic.
The Guardian included
The Teaches of Peaches in its
1000 Albums to Hear Before You Die.
Slant Magazine placed it at No. 236 on its
Best of the Aughts: Albums list.
SPIN placed it at No. 10 on the
Ten Memorable Albums From Forgotten Genres for
electroclash.
The Village Voice ranked it among the
Best Albums of 2000. At a performance on July 22, 2015, Trey Anastasio of
Phish called
The Teaches of Peaches the "greatest album ever". In 2015, the album won the 2000s category of the inaugural Slaight Family Polaris Heritage Prize, an annual Canadian music award for classic albums released prior to the creation of the
Polaris Music Prize.
The Teaches of Peaches was included on
The Guardian's 100 Best Albums of the 21st Century list, based on a 2019 poll of music writers. "The first four tracks are incredible," remarked
Iggy Pop. "The way she uses the drum machine gives it a great sense of space. 'Fuck the Pain Away' is a great song. It sounds like the title to a
Stooges track." ==Chart performance==