Main Season 1 •
James Wolk as Jordan Evans, a restaurateur in New York City who sets out to exact revenge against the men responsible for his fiancée's death. Jordan's fairy-tale counterpart is the Big Bad Wolf from
The Three Little Pigs. •
Billy Magnussen as Joshua "Nick" Sullivan, a high school teacher who engages in a relationship with one of his students. Nick's fairy-tale counterpart is the Wolf from
Little Red Riding Hood. •
Dania Ramirez as Hannah Perez, an Army veteran who returns to her hometown of New York City and who has issues with her mother and her stepfather. Hannah's fairy-tale counterpart is Hansel from
Hansel and Gretel. •
Danielle Campbell as Kayla Powell, a high school senior still processing her mother's death who recently moved to New York City with her father. Kayla's fairy-tale counterpart is Little Red Riding Hood from
Little Red Riding Hood. •
Dorian Crossmond Missick as Sam Reynolds, an NYPD detective who secretly leads a group of criminals. Sam's fairy-tale counterpart is the third little pig from
The Three Little Pigs. •
Sam Jaeger as Tim Powell, a widowed father who moves to New York City with his daughter following his wife's death. Tim's fairy-tale counterparts are Little Red Riding Hood's mother and the Woodcutter from
Little Red Riding Hood. •
Davi Santos as Gabe Perez, Hannah's brother who accidentally kills someone and who has a drug addiction. Gabe's fairy-tale counterpart is Gretel from
Hansel and Gretel. •
Michael Raymond-James as Mitch Longo, a blue-collar worker who struggles to provide for his wife and occasionally pulls off crimes with his brother Eddie. Mitch's fairy-tale counterpart is the second little pig from
The Three Little Pigs. •
Zabryna Guevara as Renee Garcia, a detective with the New York Police Department. •
Paul Wesley as Eddie Longo, a bartender and low-level drug dealer and Mitch's brother who operates as a part-time thief to pay off his debts. Eddie's fairy-tale counterpart is the first little pig from
The Three Little Pigs. •
Kim Cattrall as Colleen Powell, a former chorus girl and Tim's mother. Colleen's fairy-tale counterpart is Little Red Riding Hood's grandmother from
Little Red Riding Hood.
Season 2 •
Paul Wesley as Tucker Reed, an aspiring writer trying to prove his worth who struggles with a dark and catastrophic secret. Olivia's fairy-tale counterpart is the titular princess from
Sleeping Beauty. •
Matt Lauria as Jackson Pruitt, the black sheep of a family who is torn between his demons and the desire to be a better man. Jackson's fairy-tale counterpart is the Prince from
Cinderella. •
Eka Darville as Beau Morris, a police officer who struggles to navigate his new reality after his adherence to a moral code blows up both his personal and professional life. Beau's fairy-tale counterpart is Beauty from
Beauty and the Beast. •
Natalie Alyn Lind as Ashley Rose Pruitt, a rising country music star who survives a brutal attack, then confines herself to her home. Ashley's fairy-tale counterpart is the Beast from
Beauty and the Beast. •
Ashley Madekwe as Simone Garland, a mysterious young woman who is forced to come face-to-face with the life she purposefully left behind and will put her own life in danger to uncover her family's dark secrets. Simone's fairy-tale counterpart is Cinderella from
Cinderella. •
Carrie-Anne Moss as Rebecca Pruitt, Ashley's mother and a single mother of three who faces relationship problems with her children, and who finally starts to live for herself.
Recurring Season 1 •
Paulina Singer as Laney Reed, a classmate of Kayla's whom she quickly befriends and shares her secrets with. •
Kurt Yaeger as Terry, Hannah's veteran friend from the war who is disabled, but still sharp at his craft for long-range shooting. He joins forces with Hannah against the people who threaten her. •
Becki Newton as Katrina Thorne, the manager of the hotel where Tim works, and later his girlfriend. She also harbors secrets of her own, each with their own deadly goals. Katrina's fairy-tale counterpart is the Witch from
Hansel and Gretel. •
Spencer Grammer as Beth, Jordan's girlfriend who was killed and later guides him on his quest as a figment of his imagination. • Rarmian Newton as Ethan Davies, a classmate of Kayla's who becomes obsessed with her and appears to have signs of a dangerous mental illness. •
Justine Cotsonas as Carla, Eddie's girlfriend who he wants to run away with. • Tonya Glanz as Shelley, Mitch's wife who knows nothing of what he really did and who he is. •
James Martinez as Olsen, a dirty cop working for Sam. •
Debra Monk as Esther Thorne, Katrina's mother who works for her daughter in kidnapping and getting what she wants from their clients. •
Luke Guldan as Billy, Gabe's friend and roommate who is also a stripper and sex worker. •
Jennifer Ikeda as Rita, someone working with Jordan to find out who killed Beth. •
Sanjit De Silva as Mark, someone working with Jordan to find out who killed Beth. •
Dan Amboyer as Blake, a male stripper and sex worker who works with Billy and Gabe. •
Polly Draper as Madeline, Hannah and Gabe's mother who abandoned them and their father many years ago, and who Hannah resents. • Claire Saunders as Vicki, a friend of Kayla. •
David Andrews as Richard Winston, Hannah and Gabe's step-father who truly cares for them and wants to help them. •
Elliot Villar as Detective Herrera, one of two cops who are investigating Beth's murder. • Quincy Chad as Detective Grant, one of two cops who are investigating Beth's murder. •
Simone Missick as Mariana Reynolds, Sam's wife who is in the dark.
Season 2 •
Kathryn Prescott as Susie, Ashley Rose Pruitt's friend and assistant. •
Phillip Rhys as Damien Hewett, a slick, straight-shooting record executive to rising country music singer Ashley Rose Pruitt. • Casey Thomas Brown as Kyle Verafield, a man with a dark obsession for Ashley. •
Evan Parke as Ken Morris, Beau's father who is hired by Ashley's label to protect her following her accident. Ken's fairy-tale counterpart is the Merchant from
Beauty and the Beast. •
Garcelle Beauvais as Veronica Garland, Simone's stepmother who is protective of her status and her two sons. Veronica's fairy-tale counterpart is the Wicked Stepmother from
Cinderella. •
Caleb Castille as Ron Garland, the smart, dominant older sibling to Derek. Ron's fairy-tale counterpart is one of the Wicked Stepsisters from
Cinderella. • Christopher Meyer as Derek Garland, the soft-spoken, fiercely loyal younger sibling to Ron. Derek's fairy-tale counterpart is one of the Wicked Stepsisters from
Cinderella. •
Harry Shum Jr. as Brendan, a lawyer and Maddie's ex-boyfriend. • Audrey Corsa as Taylor, a woman who has a hidden rage within and tries to protect her boyfriend after he does something horrible. •
Julia Campbell as Cora, Simone's godmother. Cora's fairy-tale counterpart is the Fairy Godmother from
Cinderella. •
Felisha Terrell as Detective Gwen Roberts, Beau's old partner who is investigating Ashley's case. •
Matt Walton as Clay Callaway, Simone's father's lawyer who is mysteriously involved in his death and with Veronica. • Karina Logue as Donna Kading, a woman Jackson meets when he begins attending Alcoholics Anonymous.
Guest •
Marguerite Moreau as Abby Powell, Kayla's mother who mysteriously died. (season 1) •
Charles Esten as Ronnie Pruitt, Jackson, Ashley, and Maddie's deceased father who played music and was an alcoholic. He was especially close to Jackson. (season 2) ==Episodes==