The Con received positive reviews from the media, scoring 80 out of 100 on review aggregator
Metacritic.
AllMusic gave the album four stars out of five, saying that "Though each sister writes and sings lead on seven tracks, it is Sara especially who writes the more intricate pieces ("Relief Next to Me," "Like O, Like H"), showing a more adult songwriter, one who has matured since her first work came out, while Tegan draws more from simpler emo and pop-punk arrangements ("Nineteen," "Hop a Plane"), her songs more straightforward, both compositionally and lyrically, than her sister's." Adding "But this isn't to say that there's a kind of disparity or harsh contrast on The Con."
BBC said that "Throughout
The Con Tegan and Sara navigate a course that is both experimental and faithful to their pop music past. Alongside the lighter, less emotionally fraught leanings is a countering sharpness that cuts to the quick." Ending the review saying "With chameleonic deftness, Tegan and Sara have created a mystifyingly absurd but extraordinary album."
The Observer writer Sarah Boden gave the album five stars out of five saying that "On
The Con, their fifth album, the writing has acquired a melancholy, sophisticated bloom – the 14 songs here have a burnish that initially disguises end-of-the-affair wretchedness. Better still, it doesn't muddle emotion with overwrought hysterics." Ending with "When your heart feels like a stone in your breast,
The Con will prove a perfect, sweetly addictive companion." Jessica Suarez of
Pitchfork gave the album a 6.6 out of 10 saying that "Yet the record's most interesting bits-- a keen sense of melody-- disappear too quickly and can't carry the album over its production bumps. The edgiest thing about the sisters Quin continues to be their haircuts." Ending that ""Relief Next to Me" thumps like wet newspaper though, her weak similes never building up to a satisfying payoff: a big chorus, a cute melody. "Relief" gets one thing right though: When Sara sings about things "in the dark", you get the feeling that, for much of their young, female audience anyway, they can serve as a beacon."
Accolades ==Music videos==