The film was met with very negative reviews from critics, many of which were heavily critical of its satanic imagery and Cosby's performance.
Vincent Canby of
The New York Times wrote that the film "is neither the worst nor, certainly, the best of the lot."
Variety wrote, "Though starting out well, film falls on its face fast, and never recovers."
Gene Siskel of the
Chicago Tribune was positive, giving the film three stars out of four and calling it "a surprising success. Newspapers have been filled with stories commenting of the demise of the Disney magic, but 'The Devil and Max Devlin' shows signs that someone is living in the 1980s on the Disney Burbank lot. This is a very funny little movie."
Sheila Benson of the
Los Angeles Times wrote, "Somewhere inside 'The Devil and Max Devlin' (citywide), a lively, well-thought-out script (by Mary Rogers) struggles against layers of Disneyfication ... Cosby, in an unsympathetic first for him, has nothing which stretches either his comedic or his acting gifts." Gary Arnold of
The Washington Post wrote, "It's no fun at all watching a lumpy, glum Elliott Gould going through the motions of preying on a group of children before reforming himself with the foregone conclusion of a last-minute change of heart. The real self-image problem may exist at the Disney organization, which appears to be groping desperately for less innocuous story material." As of May 2024, the film holds an 17% score on
Rotten Tomatoes based on 12 reviews. It was considered controversial for Disney, particularly for its darker subject material and Cosby's portrayal of a villainous character. It was also not a sizable moneymaker for the studio; it came in 45th place in the yearly U.S. box office race with a $16 million gross, but an August 1981 article in the
New York Times quoted
Ron W. Miller as saying that it lost money. The suspension was only temporary; the film had already passed the
BBFC classification with an A rating in cinemas in 1981 and again with a PG in 1982 for videocassette and 2006 for DVD. Though Jimmy Sangster received on-screen credit for the film's story but not the screenplay, he said of the experience: "My only consolation in the affair (apart from the money) was the fact that I got to share a screen credit with the daughter of Richard Rodgers ... that's the Richard Rodgers who wrote all the great musicals. Would that his daughter had been as good a screenwriter as her father was a musician." == See also ==