In a review of
The Disney Album for
AllMusic, Jonathan Widran described Crawford as having "one of the most incredible and powerful voices on the planet", and that "the pairing of [his voice] with some of Disney's top songs (mostly from films of recent years) seems a sure bet." Widran went on to say that the album is "beautifully produced", with Crawford being "backed by beautiful strings and a children's choir on "Your Heart Will Lead You Home"". On a slightly more negative note, Widran opined that because Crawford is "so eloquent and perfect, [...] some of the whimsy and edge of the original songs is lost on his versions", singling out "
You'll Be in My Heart" as "pleasantly upbeat in an
adult contemporary manner, but [lacking] the percussive fire and vocal edge of
Phil Collins' take." He also said that "Certain elements of "
The Lion King Medley" require a little more grit [...], though he shines on the "
Can You Feel the Love Tonight" passage." Crawford is described by Widran as bringing "an emotional power" to "
Colors of the Wind", but with "not quite enough of the original spirit", and that he "is much more effective on the simpler ballads like "I Know the Truth" [...] and especially
Dumbo's classic "
Baby Mine," to which he brings the necessary grace and innocence." Christopher Thelen from The Daily Vault wrote that "On the surface, Michael Crawford seems to be the obvious choice to cover a collection of classic songs from the Walt Disney library [as he] is the voice who gave life to
the title character in
The Phantom of the Opera", and that "On paper, it seems like a match made in heaven." However, Thelen opined that on many of the tracks "it almost sounds like he's giving a
rote performance", and that Crawford "speaks his way through songs like "Colors of the Wind"; on others like "You'll Be in My Heart," he almost sounds like a
lounge singer." Thelen went on to say that "Crawford's heart may have been in the right place when he chose these songs, but he doesn't do the original singers any service", though he singled out "Baby Mine" and "I Know the Truth" as the album's "two lone highlights"; the former being described as "absolutely heart-rendering". ==Track listing==