's songwriting received mixed reviews.|alt=Photograph of composer Alan Menken attending a guild event.|244x244px Dominick Suzanne-Mayer of
Consequence of Sound praised the track for featuring "surprisingly cutting" lyrics, "pointed commentary on racism, and a dynamic, soulful performance from Judy Kuhn all in one place."
Time Raisa Bruner deemed "Colors of the Wind" one of the "powerful, uplifting theme songs" from the
Disney Renaissance and a "classic". Jordan Appugliesi of
Mic ranked it the sixth best song from a Disney soundtrack, saying that it is "a poignant, memorable ballad" in the vein of "
Reflection" from
Mulan (1998). Dorkys Ramos of
Time Out said that the song and "
When You Wish Upon a Star" from
Pinocchio (1940) are "at the top of our list when it comes to songs we don't tire of hearing again and again."
Spin Andrew Unterberger criticized the track's "patronizing" portrayal of Native American beliefs, but said that "man...Judy Kuhn's voice soars, with those little trills and sweeping highs. It makes it much easier to get behind what's ultimately an agreeable message of environmental awareness and acceptance." Aylin Zafar of
BuzzFeed ranked "Colors of the Wind" the ninth best Disney song, commending it for "encourag[ing] people to appreciate the world around them and to seek to understand others before judging them."
Screen Rant's Turner Minton viewed "Colors of the Wind" as the tenth best Disney song and "an anthem about the harmonious nature of the shared world which embraces all races of people." Charles Solomon of the
Los Angeles Times viewed "Colors of the Wind" and "
When She Loved Me" from
Toy Story 2 (1999) as the only Disney songs released since Howard Ashman's death which "approached the standards" of the music from
Beauty and the Beast (1991) and
Aladdin (1992). The staff of
People said that the track is "performed effectively within the body of the film by Kuhn".
CollegeHumor's Willie Muse wrote that "even though
Pocahontas as a whole is completely forgettable, I guarantee everyone reading this knows every single lyric of ["Colors of the Wind"]. Beautiful to listen to and epic in its scope, 'Colors of the Wind' transcends the movie that birthed it to earn its place as an undeniable classic."
Janet Maslin of
The New York Times deemed the song "heartfelt" but less catchy than previous Disney songs.
Owen Gleiberman of
Entertainment Weekly stated that
Pocahontas "Alan Menken-Stephen Schwartz songs have all the flavor of uncooked dough".
Peter Travers of
Rolling Stone criticized the song for its "
political correctness" and for "sermoniz[ing] about ecology by using pedestrian conceits". The track won the
Academy Award for Best Original Song, the
Golden Globe Award for Best Original Song, and the
Grammy Award for Best Song Written for Visual Media. ==Certifications==