The New York Times described the film as a "flashback to a time when baggy basketball shorts, hip-hop music and black shoes were considered controversial and an affront to hoops purists". Among those critical of the racial commentary was Duke player Grant Hill, who was cited in an
Associated Press story that ran in major national media outlets. Hill blogged on
The New York Times with a response naming a litany of Dukies castigated by Rose's general aspersions. His response was at the top of
The New York Times "most-emailed list" for several days and was shared on
Facebook by nearly 100,000 people within its first few days. King responded to Hill in
The Wall Street Journal. In the midst of the media exchange, the 2011 editions of the teams advanced to meet on March 20 at 2011 NCAA Tournament West Regional in
Charlotte, North Carolina, at the
Time Warner Cable Arena with Duke ranked as a #1 seed and Michigan as an #8 seed. Duke head coach Mike Krzyzewski did not respond until after both teams were eliminated from the tournament, but he noted that he felt the statements were insulting and gave specific reasons why each of the Fab Five members did not go to Duke. Duke player and Michigan native
Shane Battier supported Hill's statements saying, "
Maya Angelou couldn’t have written it and expressed it better." The
Detroit Free Press' Mark Snyder regarded
The Fab Five as a "Warts and all" depiction that was "riveting, brutal in its honesty, realistic in its language and stunning in its archival footage." Nonetheless, some questioned why Webber declined to participate and speculate on various reasons. Another Michigan writer from
SB Nation described the film as thorough in its ability to provide the viewer with the answers to natural intrigues such as: "How was the recruiting class assembled? Who pushed for the baggy shorts? The black socks? How did a stodgy University of Michigan culture react to this bold, brash and outspoken team?" He also commended the film on its detail surrounding Chris Webber's infamous timeout in the 1993 NCAA championship. The same reviewer enumerated his five biggest omissions from the film: Michigan
athletic director Bill Martin,
1991–92 Duke Blue Devils men's basketball team,
1992–93 North Carolina Tar Heels men's basketball team, Michael Talley and Webber. He was also critical of Mitch Albom's involvement with the Fab Five.
Rivals.com spoke against the tone of the film, which shows a lack of respect for team values. However, in describing the payment scandal, Webber's related legal problems and the removal of the Fab Five's banners from
Crisler Arena, and the infamous timeout gaffe at the end of the 1993 national championship game at the
1993 NCAA Men's Division I Basketball Tournament the documentary was considered fearless. All of the Wolverines who took part in the production of the film described how they felt they originated the baggy shorts as a result of Rose's request. Even rapper
Ice Cube described his recollection of them as the originators. ==See also==