Barnard conceived the sculpture in 1894. Originally it was intended to be a fountain sculpture for the courtyard of
The Dakota, a luxury apartment building on
Manhattan's
Upper West Side.
Alfred Corning Clark, an heir to the
Singer Sewing Machine fortune, was Barnard's most important early patron. Clark visited
Paris in 1895 and commissioned Barnard to proceed with the larger-than-life-size sculpture, The city's Art Commission approved acceptance of the gift, but the city's Parks Commission spent six months debating the suitability of the work and considering various Central Park locations before declining the Clark family's offer.
Bronze casting Barnard wanted his plaster sculpture cast in bronze in a single piece—as opposed to assembled from separately-cast pieces—but could not find a French foundry willing to attempt it. Barnard's plaster model for the sculpture's base featured a rock surrounded by
reeds and
cattails, with a standing
crane to visually balance Pan's head. He also modeled
Laughing Faun, a small mask to cover the
water spouts around the sculpture's base. The idea of
Pan as a fountain sculpture was abandoned following the Parks Commission's rejection; Barnard's base was never cast in bronze, and the faun masks were not used. The bronze
Pan was installed in front of the art gallery and the marble
Two Natures within the gallery. He was awarded a Gold Medal for the two sculptures. In November 1902, the bronze
Pan was among the four works shown by Barnard at the
National Sculpture Society exhibition at
Madison Square Garden, New York City. The bronze
Pan was exhibited at the
1904 World's Fair in
St. Louis, Missouri, as part of an industrial display inside the Palace of Manufactures. The Henry-Bonnard Bronze Company was awarded a Gold Medal for its accomplishment in casting the sculpture, but Barnard was not recognized for
Pan artistic merit. The plaster cast of
Pan was included in the
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston's one-man exhibition of Barnard's work, November–December 1908.
Columbia University Following the second rejection of
Pan for Central Park, Edward Clark and his mother donated the bronze sculpture to Columbia College (now
Columbia University).. The Pan Fountain was installed in 1907 on The Green at Amsterdam Avenue and 120th Street, then the northeast corner of the campus. The sculpture inspired a poem by Ralph Perry, editor of the 1916 yearbook,
The Columbian: :::::To the Great God Pan In 1959, to make way for construction of the
Seeley W. Mudd Engineering Building, Columbia relocated the
Pan statue and its granite base—but not its architectural setting and fountain—to Amsterdam Avenue and 119th Street. ==Critical reception==