Early years (1986–1991) Evan Dando,
Ben Deily and
Jesse Peretz formed the Lemonheads as teenagers at the
Commonwealth School in
Boston. The band was originally called the Whelps, until inspiration came from a
brand of candy, which Dando noted was "sweet on the inside and sour on the outside." The band recorded and self-released the 7-inch EP
Laughing All the Way to the Cleaners. The band's first show was played on August 19, 1986. After high school, Dando enrolled at
Skidmore College but could not maintain his grades and dropped out to pursue a musical career. Having signed to local label
Taang! Records, the Lemonheads released the albums
Hate Your Friends (1987),
Creator (1988), and
Lick (1989) with Deily and Dando sharing lead vocals and songwriting duties. During 1992–1993, Dando's face graced many magazine covers, and he was included in
Peoples 50 Most Beautiful People list. Now consisting of Dando, Dalton, and Ryan, the band officially renamed themselves from "Lemonheads" to "The Lemonheads" prior to the release of
Come on Feel the Lemonheads in October 1993. Dando befriended
Oasis and appeared at the band's live shows. The cracks were beginning to show, and after one particularly disjointed interview with Dando almost unable to speak, having lost his voice after smoking
crack cocaine, he admitted to having a drug problem. The band went on hiatus and Dando went into rehab. In 1996, Dando re-formed the Lemonheads with a completely new lineup, including drummer Murph (formerly of
Dinosaur Jr.), bassist Bill Gibson (formerly of the Eastern Dark), and guitarist John Strohm (formerly of the
Blake Babies; Strohm had also played drums with the Lemonheads during their early years). This band produced another Lemonheads album,
Car Button Cloth. While featuring jangly guitar songs such as "If I Could Talk I'd Tell You," this set also showed off the darker side of Dando's writing. A deluxe reissue of Lemonheads' 1992 album ''It's a Shame About Ray'' was released in March 2008 (US) and April 2008 (UK) on
Rhino Records, On June 23, 2009, the Lemonheads released
Varshons – a collection of eleven covers, including tracks by
Gram Parsons,
Wire,
GG Allin, and
Christina Aguilera. The album also featured actress
Liv Tyler performing a
duet on
Leonard Cohen's "Hey That's No Way To Say Goodbye". Despite several websites reporting a release date of September 13, 2008, the album was not released on this date. Later, in a blog post on the band's MySpace page, Dando hinted at a March 2009 release. On March 27, 2009, it was announced that Varshons would be released on June 23 on
The End Records. In an August 2007 interview, drummer
Bill Stevenson stated that he was going to produce the Lemonheads' ninth album of original material. As of August 2010, however, announcements of a new album have not yet been released. In September 2010 the Lemonheads announced an Australian tour playing all thirteen songs from the 1992 album ''
It's a Shame about Ray'', plus a selection of songs from other albums. On February 7, 2012, the Lemonheads will release Hotel Sessions on Hall of Records/Breath of Saltwater – an intimate recording documenting a Sunday night that Evan Dando spent recording new songs with just an acoustic guitar (and some revealing commentary) in a hotel room in Bondi Beach, Australia. The 14 songs include some that never made it to an official Lemonheads album, but Dando says, "the "Into Your Arms" I did here is better than the one on the album (I like it anyway)." The Lemonheads completed a 9-week U.S. tour in spring of 2012 playing all thirteen songs from the 1992 album ''
It's a Shame about Ray'', plus a selection of songs from other albums. Lead singer
Evan Dando recruited drummer
Chuck Treece and former
Taking Back Sunday lead guitarist
Fred Mascherino to play bass.
Juliana Hatfield rejoined the Lemonheads for a late 2012 tour supporting
the Psychedelic Furs. On September 17, 2012, Ryan Adams tweeted that he would be playing drums on a new 'punker sounding' Lemonheads album as well as producing it. He also announced that Evan Dando would be joined on the record by Juliana Hatfield and, for the first time since 1989's Lick, co-founder and original co-songwriter Ben Deily. Like the earlier Bill Stevenson produced sessions, however, no album was released. The Lemonheads played a seven-date tour in Ireland and the UK in October 2015. On August 14, 2017,
Atlantic Records divested the Lemonheads' back catalog to
Fire Records, which released several of the band's albums in the UK. A second album of covers (the band's first album in a decade), titled
Varshons 2, was released in 2019. In September 2025, a performance by the Lemonheads at the Vintage Industrial Bar in
Zagreb, Croatia, was cut short after frontman Evan Dando left the stage mid-set. The Croatian newspaper
Jutarnji list described the show as disorganized and reported that Dando appeared visibly distressed and smashed stage equipment before ending the concert. ==Musical style==