Scholarly reception Shortly after its publication, the work was regarded by various researchers as a "landmark" or as an important contribution to Islamic research. Gavin McDowell of
Laval University described the book as follows: The University Platform for Research on Islam (PLURIEL) promoted the book and provided an opportunity to organize research seminars and introductory seminars at
Aix-Marseille University.
UNESCO and the
University of Kufa also organized a conference on the book, as did the French Institute of Islamic Cultures.
Islamic reception The
Iranian Ahl al-Bayt International University, recommended reading the book and organized a research seminar focused on it in 2022.
The Quran of Historians was cited in the latest work of
Muhammad Shahrur. Hisham Abdel Gawad considered this publication as "another step towards popularizing the
historical-critical approach among the general public, including the Muslim audience." The Arabic-speaking website Ahewar highlighted its publication and provided positive commentary. According to Syrian philosopher Hashim Saleh, it is the "most important book of the 21st century." However, an Iranian
Shiite preacher criticized the work, accusing it of being part of a Western
conspiracy to destroy
Islam. In contrast, a Moroccan writer accused the book of being a
Shia propaganda directed against
Sunni Islam.
Media coverage Radio France featured the book in a program with
Mohammad Ali Amir-Moezzi and in a series of episodes dedicated to the subject. Another program on
France Culture invited him along with
Muriel Debié and Guillaume Dye.
Le Monde devoted a laudatory article to the book. a socialist French newspaper, had written articles about the publication of
The Quran of Historians,
Riposte Laïque!, a far-right French website, accused the book of being an "apology for Islam."
Others The
Roshan Cultural Heritage Institute congratulated Mohammad Ali Amir-Moezzi for the publication of this book. == References ==