The Soul Sessions Vol. 2 received generally mixed reviews from music critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalised rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, the album received an
average score of 60, based on 11 reviews.
Mojo magazine said it "sounds like a calculated genre exercise", while Kyle Anderson of
Entertainment Weekly found the covers "passionately pointless" when compared to the originals.
Slant Magazines Jonathan Keefe said the album sounds commonplace because of its attempt to recreate "a vintage R&B vibe rather than looking to classic styles as a source of inspiration for something more contemporary or creative". Hermione Hoby of
The Observer wrote that Stone's singing is "technically irreproachable throughout, [but] every track is attacked with all the timidity of a tsunami—enough to prompt the peevish complaint that force and feeling are not the same thing."
Jody Rosen, writing in
Rolling Stone, was more critical and felt Stone's "musical instincts are off [...] she steamrolls nearly every song with her bombastic blues growl." In a more enthusiastic review for
AllMusic, critic
Stephen Thomas Erlewine believed "for the most part,
The Soul Sessions, Vol. 2 does feel right: it has the form and sound of classic soul while never acknowledging that R&B continued to develop past, say, 1972. For an audience that agrees with that thesis, this is fun."
The Guardians Dave Simpson described the album as "a powerful, heartfelt and classy comeback", claiming that Stone has "certainly returned to her debut's soul covers format in more mature and superb voice." Hal Horowitz of
American Songwriter called the album "pretty terrific" as it "proves the UK singer is serious about her classic American R&B". John Aizlewood of
BBC Music viewed
The Soul Sessions Vol. 2 as "Stone's most focused and rewarding album since
Vol 1". ==Commercial performance==