Many authors have written that the film is the earliest example of a
jiangshi film based on Chinese folklore and have noted its impact on future films of the genre. Author Michael Thomason wrote, "It should be pointed out that, though often cited as the first major jiang shi feature, Shaw Brothers studios preceded
Mr. Vampire by six years with
Liu Chia Liang's martial arts-horror-comedy The Spiritual Boxer II (1979) (aka: The Shadow Boxing), which not only showcased the jiang shi but also delved into the ritual of corpse-walking and the world of the corpse herders." In the book
Hong Kong Action Cinema (1996), author Bey Logan wrote, "Although
Mr Vampire is regarded, justifiably, as the film that set a legion of ghouls hopping across Hong Kong movie screens, credit for first discovering this particular brand of the undead should go to director Lau Kar Leung. His Shaws production, The Spiritual Boxer 2 (1979), predates the Golden Harvest film by six years and stars Wong Yu as a young student of necromancy who must impersonate a missing corpse, under his sifu's orders, so as to placate the man's grieving relatives."
Andrew Heskins of
EasternKicks wrote, "
Sammo Hung directed himself in the film that took the idea of hopping vampires/deceased from
The Shadow Boxing (aka
The Spiritual Boxer II) and turned it into a phenomenon with
Encounter of the Spooky Kind, and things were never the same." In the book
Draculas, Vampires, and Other Undead Forms: Essays on Gender, Race, and Culture (2009), author Wayne Stein wrote, "With Spiritual Boxer II,
Leong adds an important ingredient that Jackie Chan’s success had helped to inaugurate: humor. This time, he throws out the typical traits held by Western vampires, particularly seen in the tradition of Dracula. Leong adopts the Chinese variation on the vampire with the jiangshi, which he resurrects from old folktales. [...] Also, the apprentice to the Taoist master, played by Yu Wong, fights using a curious and comedic style and shows more vigor by fighting like a vampire with stiff joints. Indeed, he is only successful when he becomes enchanted like a jiangshi and fights using his vampire 'stiff-joint' style. More importantly, it is here that Leong's genius for invention lies, which unfortunately received little or no attention from the critics. Nonetheless, Leong's absurdly funny but completely fresh action sequences would later become a fundamental tradition of this future genre of horror. [...] Though the film saw little success at the box office, its contribution to the genre has endured by helping to initiate many of the tropes that future Chinese comedy vampire films eventually adopt. Thus, a new tradition was born, and improvements come when Sammo Hung pushes this new cinematic expression of horror even further." ==References==