Time's
Stephanie Zacharek said the film "occupies that vast middle zone of small-screen movies that easily fill the void of a few empty hours, if you happen to have any to spare, though it's nothing you'd carve out time in your schedule to watch." Brian Lowry of
CNN said it "capitalizes on Gadot's inherent likability – a ruthless agent burdened by, yes, a heart – without bringing enough distinctive elements to this exercise to make it feel like much more than a
Mission wannabe."
The Independent's Clarisse Loughrey gave it two out of five stars, writing, "Heart of Stone is an ideological mess. AI is great until it's not, and then it's fine because Gal Gadot can just kick someone in the face. It's conflicted without embracing that conflict, resulting in a film that's really about nothing at all." Wendy Ide of
The Observer gave it three out of five stars, calling the screenplay "a rudimentary thing – scaffolding to support the set pieces – that starts to creak whenever it attempts any depth of character", but praising the action as "terrific, with a screaming, tyre-shredding extended car chase around Lisbon's tight, cobbled alleys a breathless and exhilarating highlight."
Richard Roeper of the
Chicago Sun-Times gave it three out of four stars, writing, "
Heart of Stone is clearly intended to jump-start an action franchise for Gadot, and it's off to a promising start."
Year-end lists Heart of Stone appeared on the "Worst Films of 2023" lists: in
Variety's year-end list, critic
Owen Gleiberman ranked "Heart of Stone" as the 5th worst film of the year. His review pointed to weak storytelling and lackluster performances, highlighting how the film missed the mark in an increasingly competitive genre. Irish critics Donald Clarke and Tara Brady from
The Irish Times placed the film at 9th on their "Worst of the Year" list, adding their voices to the growing disappointment from both American and European reviewers. Their critique echoed sentiments that the movie failed to stand out despite its high-stakes narrative and action sequences. At
ScreenCrush, Matt Singer ranked "Heart of Stone" in 6th place, indicating his disapproval of its predictable plot and formulaic approach. Marlow Stern from Rolling Stone placed it in the 8th spot, further reflecting the film's overall failure to resonate with audiences and critics alike. Other reviewers, such as Chris Evangelista from
/Film, Dominic Griffin from
Baltimore Beat, and Meghan Cook from
Insider, included the film on their lists as well, cementing "Heart of Stone" as one of the year's most criticized releases. Their shared criticisms point to an overall consensus that the film did not meet the expectations set by its promotional hype, ultimately making it a major disappointment for 2023.
Accolades ==References==