In a "POP SPOTLIGHT" review for
Billboard, the album was praised as "most persuasive" and was predicted to draw "an enormous amount of play from the top good music stations." The review noted that the set was "loaded with goodies sung in most dramatic fashion," highlighting Streisand's "slow ballad version of 'Happy Days Are Here Again'" as a particular draw, along with "many of the other tracks."
Cashbox declared that "once in a great while a new singer comes along who deserves special attention. Such an artist is Barbra Streisand." The review praised her "highly-distinctive, throaty, wide-range, legit-styled voice and amazingly intricate sense of phrasing," noting that the "songstress dishes up some stunning Peter Matz-arranged versions of 'Cry Me A River,' 'Soon, It’s Gonna Rain' and 'Keepin' Out Of Mischief Now.'" The magazine concluded by highlighting the album's "heavy airplay potential."
AllMusic gave the album a retrospective five (out of five) stars, and called it "an essential recording in the field of pop vocals because it redefines that genre in contemporary terms," and "the first thing that strikes you listening to it, is that great voice. And it isn't just the sheer quality of the voice, its purity and its strength throughout its register, it's also the mastery of vocal effects that produce dramatic readings of the lyrics -- each song is like a one-act musical." == Track listing ==