Poe was inspired by the 1827 novel
A Voyage to the Moon by
George Tucker, under whom Poe studied at the
University of Virginia while Tucker was chairman of the faculty there.
Harry Harrison and
Malcolm Edwards, in the 1979 book
Spacecraft in Fact and Fiction, comment that Tucker's story "may [...] have been responsible" for Poe's, while
J. O. Bailey writes that Poe's story "certainly owes a great deal" to Tucker's, Bailey, in a 1942 article in the
Publications of the Modern Language Association of America analyzing Poe's sources for several stories including "Hans Pfaall", identifies several parallels between the two stories including references to
lightheadedness or
loss of consciousness upon experiencing problems with the air supply, mistaking the Moon for Earth following the reversal of gravity (
bouleversement) along the journey, and the
first-person narrator deferring discussion of scientific discoveries for personal reasons but promising to publish them separately later. Bailey concludes that Poe's sources for the story are varied and complex but that significant amounts of material are traceable to Tucker's book and that this cannot be explained by familiarity with the review of
A Voyage to the Moon published in the
American Quarterly Review in March 1828 (which had previously been posited as the explanation as Poe had made reference to the review in a note to the 1840 edition of "Hans Pfaall") as some commonalities between Tucker's story and Poe's are not mentioned in the review. ==Literary significance==