"The Vampires of Venice" was first broadcast in the United Kingdom on
BBC One on 8 May 2010. Due to an extended episode of
Over the Rainbow which was shown afterwards, the episode aired at 6:00 p.m., the earliest start time for a
Doctor Who episode since the series was revived in 2005. Perhaps due to this, the episode received the lowest overnight figures of the series at time of broadcast: 6.17 million on BBC One and
simulcast BBC HD. When final consolidated ratings were calculated, it was shown that the episode had been watched by a total of 7.68 million viewers, coming in fifth place on BBC One for the week. The episode received an
Appreciation Index of 86, considered "excellent". "The Vampires of Venice" was released in
Region 2 on DVD and Blu-ray with the preceding episodes "
The Time of Angels" and "
Flesh and Stone" on 5 July 2010. It was then re-released as part of the Complete Fifth Series boxset on 8 November 2010.
Critical reception The episode received mixed reviews. Daniel Martin, writing for
The Guardian on
guardian.co.uk, described it as "beautifully shot" and went on to write: "the way every part of the vampire mythos was explained away by
Who pseudo-science was delightful; the stand-off between the Doctor and Rosanna was beautifully played; the dialogue as cracking as you'd expect from Whithouse...and the climactic shot of the Doctor scaling the tower in the rain was just the correct level of broad brushstroke".
SFX reviewer David Bradley also reacted positively, giving the episode four out of five stars. He assessed it as "better structured, funnier and more absorbing" than the previous single episode "
Victory of the Daleks" and praised the comedy and acting of Alex Price. However, he thought the "expensive-looking locations are let down by shonky special effects". Gavin Fuller gave the episode a negative review in
The Daily Telegraph, calling it "highly disappointing" and "a tragically wasted opportunity." He criticised the writing and plot for "sheer derivativeness", noting that the opening scene was "similar in concept" to Whithouse's previous
Doctor Who episode "
School Reunion" and thought the "aliens-posing-as-humans idea" was taken from that script as well. He went on to criticise
Lucian Msamati as Guido as he "seemed to be taken straight out of
Othello", negatively compared the
love triangle between the Doctor, Amy and Rory to the storyline with previous characters
Rose and
Mickey, and thought the ending was too similar to "
The Idiot's Lantern" and "
Evolution of the Daleks". Patrick Mulkern, writing for the
Radio Times, echoed Fuller's sentiments in his review, saying "I must admit I yawn at aliens disguised as humans. We've seen it so many times now" and noted that Whithouse had used the concept in "School Reunion" and his
Torchwood episode "
Greeks Bearing Gifts". However, he also thought that "the script delivers lots of heroics and funny moments for the Doctor, Amy and Rory", and he praised the "terrific cast", describing
Helen McCrory as "majestic".
IGN's Matt Wales rated "The Vampires of Venice" 7 out of 10, saying that it "had plenty of standout moments, even if it didn't quite manage to come together to form a completely satisfying whole". He praised the comedy between Amy and Rory and McCrory's acting, as well as the location shots and Croatia and thought "the sci-fi retcon of classic vampire phenomenon was particularly clever", believing that the aliens went beyond two-dimensional. However, he agreed with Fuller and Mulkern that "its single biggest problem was one of over-familiarity", with many misplaced alien races having featured before. ==References==