Ratings Critical response The critical reception of the opening two episodes was summarised by Martin Belam in
The Guardian as "mixed". Ed Power of
The Independent criticised the inclusion of
UNIT as a primary presence in the show, saying that "it's always been a rule of thumb that the more UNIT in an episode, the more boring the results". Power remarked that this was the case for
The War Between the Land and the Sea and awarded 2 out of 5 stars. Writing for
The Guardian, Lucy Mangan gave 3 out of 5, feeling that the spin-off was "an opportunity wasted", comparing it in an inferior light to Russell T Davies' previous show,
Years and Years. Several outlets praised the performance of returning actress Jemma Redgrave, including
Radio Times,
SciFi Pulse and
The London Standard. Isobel Lewis, writing for
The i Paper, compared the show to
Torchwood, highlighting the use of profanity. Lewis praised Davies' "willingness" to "not simply feed fans the same stories over and over", noting how the finales featuring
Ncuti Gatwa's
Fifteenth Doctor often "struggled to stick the landing". In a review for the third and fourth episodes, David Opie of
Digital Spy criticised the unsubstantial build-up of the relationship between Kate Lethbridge-Stewart and Colonel Cristofer Ibrahim, arguing "if you're going to pull off a stunt like this, you need to invest more time in the relationship before it's ripped apart." Louise Griffin, writing for
Radio Times, concluded that the sacrifice of Ibrahim allowed for Stewart to "shine on her own", beyond only "carrying the legacy of the
Brigadier." The connection between Barclay and Salt was described by Ruchika Bhat of
Digital Mafia Talkies as the show exiting
Doctor Who territory and entering into "sappy romance territory", with the different elements feeling incomplete and "such complicated themes in such a short span of time" seeming "a little bit ridiculous." Bhat praised the visual effects and
Gugu Mbatha-Raw's performance however. Writing for
Voice Magazine, Kieran Battams compared the conclusion to Barclay's story as a reversal of
The Shape of Water, whilst giving praise to Redgrave's multi-layered performance.
Gizmodo writer James Whitbrook criticised what he felt was a rushed story, feeling Barclay and Salt's relationship was not "really given any time to develop", and despite the war being mentioned in name "we never get to really see that conflict."
Soap Central writer Deanna Dsilver highlighted that
The War Between was "easy to follow", with
The End of the War "keeping that trend". ==Notes==