Reception The movie at the time of release gained an indifferent reception from critics. Review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes reported an approval rating of 71% based on 7 reviews, with an average rating of 6.9/10. Michael Thompson of
BBC.com scored it 4 out of 5. Move critic Keith Hennessey-Brown, writing for
Eye For Film, commented: "With a plot taken straight from the old comic strip Billy's Boots - albeit given a more realistic spin - I expected this film to seriously suck. Yet I came away thinking it was actually quite good. Yes, it's entirely predictable and done in a check-off-the-clichés way - the underdog has his day, justice is done as the good guys are rewarded and the bad guys punished, etc, etc - but it just plain works. Youngster Lewis McKenzie, who plays Grimble, looks like a real find. Robert Carlyle, Ray Winstone and Gina McKee are a pleasure to watch, as always, as the flawed adults who surround him. It's especially nice to see Winstone cast somewhat against type – this may be the only film he's been in where he doesn't do his violent outburst thing. Complete with a soundtrack of predominantly Manchester bands, there's Only One Jimmy Grimble is an effective feel-good film that successfully accomplishes what it sets out to."
Awards and nominations At the
Berlin Film Festival, the film won the award for Best Feature Film in the Silver Bear category. At the
Giffoni Film Festival, it won the Golden Gryphon Free to Fly Award, with a further award for the Golden Poznan Goat coming at the
Ale Kino! International Young Audience Film Festival. Lewis McKenzie was also nominated for the Best Newcomer at the
British Independent Film Awards.
Legacy In 2018 Football magazine
FourFourTwo placed the movie as the 7th of 14 on the best football movies ever. A poll in the same year by
SPORTbible asked its readers to vote for their favourite football films, with the movie placing again in 7th place with 1,456 votes. The movie has become nostalgically linked to
Manchester City, with the movie released during the same season City were relegated from the
Premier League for a second-time. This coming in the midst of golden era for local rivals
Manchester United with Gordon's bullying of Jimmy in the movie mimicking the difference in class between the two football clubs at the time. The movie's most famous line is when Jimmy is asked if he would like to sign for United, only for him to tell the United scout that he's had a better offer. "What could be better than Man United, son?" the scout asks, only for Jimmy to reply "Man City". The movie is mentioned in the school book Access 3 by the German publisher Cornelsen. It is used for studying film analysis in English second language classrooms in Germany. ==See also==