In a review for the
Wall Street Journal,
Alexander Rose wrote that "McCain and Salter have chosen a thoughtful array of subjects" and that the book was in the tradition of
Plutarch's
Parallel Lives and the romances and chronicles of
Medieval literature in revealing how character and codes of behavior can lead to greatness. However Rose disagrees with the authors' implicit assumption that soldiers across all these wars faced similar challenges or that their experiences were similarly "transforming".
Military Review said that McCain and Salter "do an incredible job of bringing to life not only the experiences and stories of the individuals being examined, but also of those who served around them." However it chided the authors for including only a general bibliography and not specific citations for possibly novel statements and said that as a consequence the book was well-suited to general audiences but not academic ones.
Kirkus Reviews summarized the book as containing "A patriotic though unsentimental look at the major wars fought by the United States as told through the difficult experiences of ordinary soldiers." McCain appeared in media interviews to promote the book and also did some book signings.
Thirteen Soldiers was published in
trade paperback in November 2015. ==References==