Contemporary 's favorite albums.
Jazz & Pops
Gene Sculatti wrote: "[the Beach Boys] have the audacity to fool around with r&b, a territory indeed alien to them. Surprisingly,
Wild Honey works well. It isn't the least bit pretentious, it's honest, and convincing." In a column for
Esquire,
Robert Christgau wrote that the album "epitomizes Brian Wilson", including the song "I'd Love Just Once to See You", which "expresses perfectly his quiet, thoughtful, sentimental artistic personality."
Billboard welcomed the band's return to form after the "avant-garde"
Smiley Smile, but was critical of "How She Boogalooed It" as "far below the group's quality" and predicted that "I'd Love Just Once to See You" would not receive airplay.
Disc & Music Echo awarded the album "LP of the Month" and wrote that it was the band's best since
Pet Sounds. The magazine concluded that "Others who, like us, felt Brian Wilson was becoming bogged down in his complex arrangements can relax and listen to the most refreshing sounds for many months." In a 1968
Crawdaddy! article,
David Anderle reported that
the Doors'
Jim Morrison considered Brian Wilson "his favorite musician" and
Wild Honey "one of his favorite albums. [...] he really got into it."
Retrospective Like
Smiley Smile,
Wild Honey was later reevaluated by fans and critics who highlighted the record for its simplicity and charm, particularly after the LP was reissued by
Warner Bros. in 1974. In his 1971 review of ''Surf's Up
, Rolling Stone
s Arthur Schmidt referred to Wild Honey'' as "a masterpiece", "the most underrated" of the band's "post-surfer LPs", and "the last time they truly rocked their asses off, one cut after another." In a 1976 retrospective guide to 1967 for
The Village Voice, Christgau felt
Wild Honey is "so slight" but "perfect and full of pleasure". He argued that, "almost without a bad second", the album conveys "the troubled innocence of the Beach Boys through a time of attractive but perilous psychedelic
sturm und drang. Its method is whimsy, candor, and carefully modulated amateurishness, all of which comes through as humor." Critic
Geoffrey Himes called the record "10 wonderful celebrations of everyday life and a terrific Stevie Wonder cover. Wonder, though, never sang odes to clean air and refreshing wind or made boyish jokes about seeing a naked woman or brushing one's teeth." Record producer
Tony Visconti listed
Wild Honey as one of his 13 favorite albums and said that "I still refer to this record as a benchmark in the same way that I do
Revolver." In 2020,
Rolling Stone ranked the record at number 410 on its list of "
The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time". Less favorably,
Richie Unterberger wrote in his review for
AllMusic that, apart from "Darlin, "Here Comes the Night" and the title track, most of
Wild Honey was "inessential". He found the music "often quite pleasant, for the great harmonies if nothing else, but the material and arrangements were quite simply thinner than they had been for a long time." In a negative review,
Pitchfork critic Spencer Owen said only "one or two" songs succeed and the majority of
Wild Honey is "not pretty" because of its R&B vein as "interpreted by white surfer boys", including "a Stevie Wonder cover sung with as much faux-soul as Carl Wilson could have possibly mustered". Writing in his
Encyclopedia of Popular Music,
Colin Larkin pairs the album with the "scrappy"
Smiley Smile as two "hastily released" works that show how the Beach Boys' music had "lost its cohesiveness", with Brian Wilson's reduced involvement.
Noel Gallagher, who considers the Beach Boys to be "the most vastly overrated band in the history of popular culture", named "How She Boogalooed It" among the group's only "six good tunes". ==Influence and legacy==