Philadelphia Eagles McDonald was selected by the
Philadelphia Eagles in the third round of the
1957 NFL draft. As a rookie, he was moved to
wide receiver after he replaced an injured
Bill Stribling in the ninth game of the season, making a 61-yard reception and a 25-yard receiving touchdown from quarterback
Sonny Jurgensen. He was a part of the team that won the
1960 NFL Championship against
Vince Lombardi’s
Green Bay Packers. In the contest, he had a 35-yard touchdown reception from quarterback
Norm Van Brocklin. In 1961, he led the NFL in receiving yards (1,144) and touchdowns (13). Against the
New York Giants, he had 7 receptions for 237 yards and 2 touchdowns, which still is a franchise single-game record. On March 20,
1964, he was traded to the
Dallas Cowboys in exchange for
Sam Baker,
John Meyers, and
Lynn Hoyem.
Dallas Cowboys In
1964, he was switched from
flanker to
split end, because the Cowboys already had an accomplished flanker in
Franklin Clarke and split end
Billy Howton had just retired. Looking to improve the receiving corps to help the young
quarterback Don Meredith, they also traded with the
Pittsburgh Steelers to get
Buddy Dial. In his only season with the club, he registered 46 receptions for 612 yards (13.3 average) and 2
touchdowns (one of them against the Eagles). In
1965, with the emergence of rookie
Bob Hayes he was traded to the
Los Angeles Rams in exchange for
placekicker Danny Villanueva on May 14.
Los Angeles Rams McDonald recorded a career-high 67 receptions for 1,036 yards and 9 touchdowns in
1965. He was selected to his last
Pro Bowl. In
1967 he was traded to the
Atlanta Falcons in exchange for a draft choice.
Atlanta Falcons On September 10,
1968, he was waived following a season with 33 receptions for 436 yards and 4 touchdowns.
Cleveland Browns In
1968, McDonald was picked up by the
Cleveland Browns for whom he caught 7 receptions for 113 yards and one touchdown. With the retirement of
Raymond Berry the previous year, McDonald was technically the league's active leader in career receiving yards during the off-season but was surpassed in Game 1 by
Don Maynard. His last NFL game was the 1968 NFL Championship Game against the Baltimore Colts. On March 15, 1969, he announced his retirement from pro football. ==NFL career statistics==