Hearings in Sheridan's defamation case against the publishers of the
News of the World began in the
Court of Session in
Edinburgh on 4 July 2006. Unusually in Scottish civil proceedings, the case was heard before a
jury. The jury heard allegations that Sheridan had visited a
swingers clubs in
Manchester and engaged in adulterous affairs with two women. Sheridan, who claims to be a
teetotaller, reportedly drank
champagne and consumed
cocaine during an extramarital liaison. Sheridan denied drinking champagne and the claim of substance abuse. Eleven members of the
SSP's executive committee testified that he admitted in an executive committee meeting to attending a swingers club with women, but another four members of the SSP who were present at that Executive meeting backed Sheridan's claim that he made no such admission at that meeting. On 14 July 2006, Sheridan sacked his legal team and began representing himself. His cross-examination of witnesses was described by one left commentator as "sickening", singling out the cross-examination of Katrine Trolle: "Sheridan questioned her about their sexual history, which included visits to Cupids with Sheridan and group sex encounters with him and his brother-in-law, Andrew McFarlane. When she stated that she was embarrassed about her past, but that she was telling the truth, Sheridan unflinching brandished her as a perjurer, plotter and gold-digger. [...] I still find it astonishing, and not a little dispiriting, that anyone on the left – any decent human being in fact – could justify traducing a female socialist's character in court, not once, but twice, in order to protect a leading socialist politician's false reputation." On 4 August 2006, Sheridan won his case with a majority verdict of 7–4 and the jury awarded him maximum damages of £200,000. The
News of the World has appealed the verdict. In the
Scottish Socialist Voice of 8 August, a letter signed by a further six leading members of the SSP claimed that Sheridan had told them that he had admitted at an SSP Executive meeting to attending the Manchester swingers club. The
News of the World intended to appeal against what they described as the "perverse" decision in the immediate aftermath of the trial, and a provisional date for the hearing was set for December 2007, however it was postponed until the outcome of the
procurator fiscal's perjury probe.
Allegations of witness intimidation On 10 October 2006,
BBC News reported that
Grampian Police were investigating a claim by Fiona McGuire, who had been a witness in the trial for the
News of the World, that she had received a death threat through the post. In a statement to the BBC, Sheridan said: "I utterly condemn any threats to Fiona McGuire or any other individual". On 26 August 2007, the
Sunday Herald reported that John Lynn had been questioned by detectives about allegations of witness tampering. Lynn is reportedly an associate of
Paul Ferris, a reformed criminal who has become friendly with Sheridan. The report said Helen Allison, who claimed in court that she saw Sheridan having sex in a Glasgow hotel, had been approached by Lynn who asked her not to give evidence. Lynn was once jailed for 17 years for shooting an
Ulster barman.
Hidden video On 1 October 2006, the
News of the World reignited controversy by publishing new evidence in support of its claim that Sheridan lied to the Court of Session. It was a video recording of Sheridan admitting he had visited a swingers club in Manchester on two occasions and further, that he had, as other senior SSP members claimed in court, admitted this at an Executive meeting of the SSP. The tape had been made without Sheridan's knowledge using a hidden camera by SSP member George McNeilage in McNeilage's house after he invited Sheridan there. McNeilage had been one of three best men at Sheridan's wedding. Sheridan does not appear clearly on the video at any time. The newspaper had not been able to produce any images from the video showing Sheridan's face and Sheridan said the video was a fake. He conceded his voice was on the tape but suggested it was spliced with clips of the voice of someone else. The
News of the World claimed four independent voice analysts had confirmed that the voice on the tape is that of Tommy Sheridan. However, in an interview with the BBC a forensic speech scientist, Peter French, said: "Experts should never say conclusively they have identified a person and this kind of evidence should never solely be used to bring a criminal trial". Sheridan then suggested that
MI5, someone within the SSP,
Rupert Murdoch and
Bill Gates had conspired to concoct the videotape to undermine his campaign for an independent socialist Scotland.
Perjury conviction The conflicting evidence given during the trial resulted in the judge warning several witnesses about the implications of perjuring themselves. On Monday 7 August 2006, Lothian and Borders Police said they had received two complaints of perjury, one from the former Conservative MSP
Brian Monteith, the other alleged to be from the SSP's minutes secretary. On 22 August 2006, the
Crown Office instructed the Edinburgh Procurators Fiscal office to ascertain if there were grounds for a criminal investigation. On 2 October 2006, it was concluded that there were and Lothian and Borders Police were instructed to start a criminal investigation. On 21 February 2007,
The Herald reported that the
Crown Office had asked
Lothian and Borders Police to undertake a full inquiry after receiving a preliminary report. In May 2007, it was reported that staff at Cupid's Swingers Club in Manchester had told police they had been offered bribes not to co-operate with the inquiry. On 16 December 2007, Sheridan was charged with perjury in relation to the
News of the World case. In a public statement outside the police station he attributed his arrest to the "powerful reach" of the Murdoch press. During February 2008, his wife Gail, former SSP MSP
Rosemary Byrne, former members of the SSP Executive Committee, Patricia Smith, Graeme McIver, Jock Penman, and Sheridan's father-in-law, Angus Healey, were also charged with perjury. On 27 January 2009, Sheridan and his wife were indicted for perjury, and were summoned to attend a pre-trial hearing at Edinburgh High Court on 26 February. however this was postponed until 11 May. The trial started at Glasgow High Court on 4 October 2010. Sheridan's initial defence team included
Donald Findlay, who was replaced by
Maggie Scott. However, a few weeks into the case, Sheridan instructed his Solicitor
Aamer Anwar, who had defended him since 2007, to withdraw Scott's instructions. He then conducted his own defence, with Anwar assisting him as
amicus curiae. On 23 December 2010 a jury found Sheridan guilty of perjury and on 26 January 2011 he was sentenced to 3 years in prison. Initially he was held in
Barlinnie prison in Glasgow, but after several weeks he was moved to a semi-open wing in Barlinnie, and on 21 June he was moved to
Castle Huntly open prison. Sheridan was released to a
Home Detention Curfew on 30 January 2012, having served just over one year of his sentence. Sheridan and Aamer Anwar subsequently parted company, with Gordon Dangerfield acting as his lawyer. In 2015 the
Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission declined to refer the case to the High Court.
Support for Sheridan A "Defend Tommy Sheridan" campaign was launched by sympathetic trade unionists and politicians to demand why Sheridan was being investigated. In December 2007,
Sunday Herald columnist
Iain MacWhirter said it was "hard not to conclude that the police's diligence has been inspired by Rupert Murdoch's News International." The campaign drew support from the politician
George Galloway and leading trade unionist
Bob Crow (RMT). At a June 2008 rally organised by the campaign, speakers including FBU secretary Kenny Ross,
Paddy Hill, and
Gerry Conlon queried the motives for the investigation, questioned the role of the police and
Crown Office and verbally attacked the witnesses who had given evidence unhelpful to Sheridan in the original hearing.
Claims of illegal surveillance In March 2007,
Lothian and Borders Police investigated claims that Tommy Sheridan had been
bugged after a suspicious device was found in his car. The device was described as "not of the kind used by British security services". A complaint submitted to Strathclyde Police in July 2011 lead to
Operation Rubicon, a major investigation involving 50 officers investigating allegations of phone hacking, breach of data protection and perjury by
News of the World. In May 2012,
Andy Coulson, editor of the
News of the World from 2003 – 2007 and who gave evidence at Sheridan's trial, was detained "on suspicion of committing perjury before the High Court in Glasgow". On 7 July 2014, following Coulson's conviction on phone hacking charges, Coulson himself faced perjury charges over Sheridan's trial, and on 23 February 2015, a pre-evidential hearing at the High Court in Edinburgh set a trial date of 21 April. On 3 June 2015, Coulson was formally acquitted after the case against him was dismissed by a judge.
News Group appeal against defamation award (2016) An appeal hearing at the Court of Session in Edinburgh against the 2006 defamation award in light of Sheridan's later perjury conviction began on 10 May 2016. New Group Newspapers (now part of
News UK) lost their appeal against the award of £200,000 damages to Sheridan on 19 August 2016.
Publications Sheridan's rise and extinction are dealt with in two works of political analysis:
Downfall by his erstwhile colleague Alan McCombes (2011), and
Tommy Sheridan: From Hero to Zero? by Gregor Gall (2012). ==Other activities==