"Tumbling Dice" received acclaim from
music critics, with many praising its musicianship.
Los Angeles Times music critic
Robert Hilburn asserted that it "features marvelously sensual guitar work by Richards" and that it should rank with "
Satisfaction", "
Street Fighting Man" and "
Honky Tonk Women" "as one of the Stones' classic concert numbers".
The Boston Globe critic Ernie Santosuosso agreed, finding the "
chorale" to be "outstanding" and the lyrics "intriguing". Peter Barsocchini described the guitar work of Richards and
Mick Taylor as "sassy" in a review for
The Times.
Record World called it an "exciting release" with a "phenomenal rhythm track, vocal chorus". Writing for the
Daily News, music critic Jerry Oster found "Tumbling Dice" and "
Happy" to be the two songs on
Exile on Main St. that had "all the energy and dynamism on which this greatness was founded" and that it came through "overpoweringly". He considered it to be "music that, in a time when dancing is dead, not only can be danced to, but must be". The drum work by Charlie Watts was also praised.
Rolling Stone critic
Lenny Kaye considered the guitar work and drumming of Watts to build to a "kind of majesty the Stones at their best have always provided". In a retrospective review for
Spin, music critic Al Shipley described every note of the song as "perfection" where every "hooky little moment" is accompanied by a "perfect Charlie Watts snare fill". David Morgan of
CBS News asserted that Watts' percussion on the single was "remarkable". Several critics complimented the tempo and groove of the single. Music critic Jack Garner asserted in a review for
Courier News that the song featured a "marvellous tempo". Shipley felt the song has an "irresistible singalong energy", describing the "breakdown and buildup into the final 'you got to roll me' refrain" as "sublime". Kaye considered the single to be "a cherry on the first side" of
Exile and the only song on the album that made "real moves towards a classic".
Ultimate Classic Rock critic Kyle Dowling agreed, calling it a "true standout" of the album and a "classic piece of rock and roll music", noting that it was a persistent favourite in live performances. Morgan agreed with Dowling, calling it a "classic". According to Janovitz,
Rod Stewart "so coveted" the song that he took a tape of it into his
Foot Loose & Fancy Free (1977) sessions "to play to the band he had assembled to record "
Hot Legs". The song has earned spots on numerous "best of" lists.
Vulture ranked the single as the seventeenth best Rolling Stones song
Rolling Stone's 2021 update ranked it number 86. == Commercial performance ==