Semi-professional On 6 May 2022, Spicer was named to the roster of
USL League Two club
Tennessee SC ahead of their inaugural season. Two days later, Spicer scored the first goal in team history when he scored the first goal of a 2–2 draw against the
Dalton Red Wolves in the opening match of the season. On 5 June, Spicer scored the second goal of a 2–0 win over
East Atlanta FC, helping to secure the team's first ever win. In total, Spicer would contribute three goals and an assist across ten appearances for the team as the club placed fifth in the
South Central Division, losing out on the playoffs. Spicer played with USL League Two club
Des Moines Menace for the
2023 USL League Two season. On 14 June, Spicer scored a brace as Des Moines defeated Springfield ASC 6–0. Des Moines Menace would ultimately qualify for the playoffs after placing second in the
Heartland Division, but Spicer would not participate in the playoffs. In total, Spicer would score two goals and contribute at least three assists across all competitions, including a brace of assists against the Menace's rivals
Des Moines United FC.
Toronto FC At the
2024 MLS SuperDraft, Spicer was selected
first overall by
Toronto FC. He pre-signed a contract prior to the draft, and his selection was announced by
Toronto Maple Leafs captain
John Tavares. Upon being drafted, Spicer said that he "will definitely surprise MLS" with his abilities. Spicer made his club debut on 16 March, in a substitute appearance against
New York City FC, and followed that up the following week on 23 March, scoring his first professional goal in his first start, in a 2–0 victory over
Atlanta United, becoming the sixth MLS SuperDraft first pick to score on his first start. Spicer's performance against Atlanta United saw him named to the
Team of the Matchday two days later. In Spicer's first professional season he would contribute three goals and two assists in 20 appearances across all competitions.
Orlando City On 1 August 2025, Spicer was traded to
Orlando City, in exchange for up to $550,000 in
General Allocation Money across two seasons. Toronto FC also retained a sell-on percentage for any future potential transfer. Following Spicer's departure from the club, Toronto FC general manager
Jason Hernandez thanked Spicer for his contributions to the team over the past two seasons, but said the transfer came about because it was communicated that Spicer "only wanted to continue with the club if certain contractual commitments and conditions were secured this summer" ahead of the end of his contract at the end of the season. Toronto FC found Spicer's demands unacceptable and opted to move him on ahead of the expiration of his contract. In an interview with
The Canadian Press, Hernandez revealed that Spicer's agent had demanded "four or five times" his current annual contract, which was US$83,122, the third-lowest on Toronto FC's roster, and that it was an easy decision to make for him to move Spicer to Orlando City. When signing with Orlando, Spicer spoke to the captain of the Trinidad & Tobago national team,
Kevin Molino, who used to play for Orlando City, about his experience with the team, and Spicer described carrying on the Trinidadian legacy in the team as a motivating factor in choosing to play for Orlando City. On 10 August, Spicer made his debut when he substituted on for
Iván Angulo in the 90th-minute in a 4–1 win over Orlando City's rivals
Inter Miami. Following his first match with Orlando, Spicer said that Orlando City is a much better team than Toronto FC and that Toronto did not contend for titles, and that his development as a professional footballer was being stunted with his former team. In the following match, six days later against
Sporting Kansas City, Spicer made his first start and scored his first goal for the team in just one minute and ten seconds. Spicer's goal trumped the previous record of 17 minutes and 54 seconds for the fastest goal scored by an Orlando City player in their first start. After the conclusion of Spicer's first season with Orlando City, the team opted to exercise his contract option, which would see him under contract through 2026. Later, on 20 December, Spicer signed a new contract which would see him signed to the club through the 2027–28 season and a club option for the next season. On 2 May 2026, Spicer scored the final goal of a 4–3 comeback win over Inter Miami, a feat which made Orlando City only the third team in league history to come back from a 3–0 deficit and win the game. ==International career==