New York elected its members April 24–26, 1821, after the term began but before the new Congress convened. The , previously a
plural district with two seats, was divided into two single-member districts for the 17th Congress, the 21st and . The Democratic-Republican party in New York was divided between "Bucktails" and "
Clintonians". The Clintonians ran on a joint ticket with the remaining Federalists. In a few cases, marked as "Clintonian/Federalist" below, it is unclear whether a candidate on the joint ticket was Democratic-Republican or Federalist. Only five of the twenty-seven incumbents were re-elected to the next term. Sixteen incumbents retired and five lost re-election. Despite this high turnover of membership, there was only a one-seat net gain for the Federalists. •
Silas Wood (Federalist) 27.1% •
Peter Sharpe (Democratic-Republican) 23.1% •
Cadwallader D. Colden (Federalist) 22.9% • Joshua Smith (Democratic-Republican) 22.8% • "Cadwallader Colden" 2.7% • "Cadwallader D. Colder" 1.5% }} •
Cadwallader D. Colden (Federalist) •
Peter Sharpe (Democratic-Republican) }} •
John J. Morgan (Democratic-Republican) 49.5% •
Churchill C. Cambreleng (Democratic-Republican) 29.6% •
Henry Eckford (Clintonian/Federalist) 20.9% }} •
Jeremiah H. Pierson (Democratic-Republican) 59.2% • John T. Smith (Clintonian/Federalist) 37.7% • Peter S. Van Orden (Democratic-Republican) 9.4% }} •
William W. Van Wyck (Democratic-Republican) 56.8% • William Taber (Clintonian/Federalist) 43.2% }} •
Walter Patterson (Federalist) 57.8% •
Philip J. Schuyler (Democratic-Republican) 42.0% }} •
Selah Tuthill (Democratic-Republican) 61.6% •
James W. Wilkin (Democratic-Republican) 38.3% }} •
Charles H. Ruggles (Federalist) 54.6% • William Gillespie (Democratic-Republican) 45.3% }} •
Richard McCarty (Democratic-Republican) 58.8% •
Jacob Haight (Democratic-Republican) 41.1% }} •
Solomon Van Rensselaer (Federalist) 57.1% •
Harmanus Bleecker (Democratic-Republican) 42.8% }} •
John D. Dickinson (Federalist) 55.5% •
James L. Hogeboom (Democratic-Republican) 42.4% • Simon Newcomb (Clintonian/Federalist) 2.0% }} •
John W. Taylor (Democratic-Republican) 53.3% • Guert Van Schoonhoven (Democratic-Republican) 46.5% }} •
Reuben H. Walworth (Democratic-Republican) 27.9% •
Nathaniel Pitcher (Democratic-Republican) 26.1% •
John Crary (Clintonian/Federalist) 23.5% •
Ezra C. Gross (Democratic-Republican) 22.5% }} •
John Gebhard (Democratic-Republican) 51.0% • William Mann (Democratic-Republican) 49.0% }} •
Alfred Conkling (Democratic-Republican) 52.4% •
John Herkimer (Democratic-Republican) 47.6% }} •
James Hawkes (Democratic-Republican) 28.5% •
Samuel Campbell (Democratic-Republican) 27.8% •
Robert Monell (Democratic-Republican) 22.3% • Alvan Stewart (Clintonian/Federalist) 21.5% }} •
Joseph Kirkland (Federalist) 56.5% •
Nathan Williams (Democratic-Republican) 43.4% }} •
Thomas H. Hubbard (Democratic-Republican) 51.0% •
David Woods (Democratic-Republican) 48.9% }} •
Micah Sterling (Federalist) 52.3% •
Perley Keyes (Democratic-Republican) 47.3% }} •
Elisha Litchfield (Democratic-Republican) 51.4% •
George Hall (Democratic-Republican) 48.5% }} •
William B. Rochester (Democratic-Republican) 29.6% •
David Woodcock (Democratic-Republican) 24.7% •
Jonathan Richmond (Democratic-Republican) 23.9% • Herman Camp (Democratic-Republican) 21.8% }} •
Elijah Spencer (Democratic-Republican) 49.6% •
Nathaniel Allen (Democratic-Republican) 48.6% • Daniel W. Lewis (Clintonian/Federalist) 1.7% }} •
Albert H. Tracy (Democratic-Republican) 50.8% •
Benjamin Ellicott (Democratic-Republican) 49.2% }} == North Carolina ==