The first reference to
Urim and Thummim in the Bible is the description in the Book of Exodus concerning the high priest's vestments; the chronologically earliest passage mentioning them, according to textual scholars, is in the
Book of Hosea, where it is implied, by reference to the Ephod, that the Urim and Thummim were fundamental elements in the popular form of the Israelite religion, however, these rabbinical sources questioned, or at least tried to justify, why Urim and Thummim would be required when a prophet was also present. The classical rabbinical writers argued that the Urim and Thummim were only permitted to be consulted by very prominent figures such as army generals, the most senior of court figures, and kings, and the only questions which could be raised were those which were asked for the benefit of the people as a whole. To uncover the sin of
Achan the sacred Lots were used by
Joshua.
Abiathar joined David, who was then in the cave of
Adullam (1 Sam. 22:20–23, 23:6). He remained with David, and became priest of the party of which he was the leader (1 Sam. 30:7). When David ascended the throne of Judah, Abiathar was appointed High Priest (1 Chr. 15:11; 1 Kings 2:26) and the "king's counselor" (1 Chr. 27:33–34). Meanwhile, Zadok, of the house of Eleazar, had been made High Priest. According to the
Jewish Encyclopedia Abiathar was deposed from office when he was deserted by the Holy Spirit without which the Urim and Thummin could not be consulted. Although
Josephus argues that the Urim and Thummim continued to function until the era of the
Maccabees, Talmudic sources are unanimous in agreeing that the Urim and Thummim stopped functioning much earlier, when
Jerusalem was sacked by the Babylonians. In a passage from the part of the
Book of Ezra which overlaps with the
Book of Nehemiah, it is mentioned that individuals who were unable to prove, after the
Babylonian captivity had ended, that they were descended from the priesthood before the captivity began, were required to wait until priests in possession of Urim and Thummim were discovered; this would appear to confirm the statements in the Talmud that the Urim and Thummim had by then been lost. states that in the
Second Temple the Urim and Thummim actually existed but no longer functioned in the practical sense since the priests no longer possessed the Holy Spirit. Rabbi
Abraham ben David disagrees and maintains that during that era, the Urim and Thummim were completely absent. According to the ancient
apocryphal
Lives of the Prophets, after the death of
Zechariah ben Jehoiada, the priests of the Temple could no longer see the apparitions of the
angel of the Lord, make
divinations with the Ephod, or give responses from the
Holy of Holies. ==Latter Day Saint movement==