After the success of
Amara Deepam (1956), director
T. Prakash Rao and co-writer
C. V. Sridhar wanted their next film to be on a grander scale. Rao decided on the folk tale of
Valli, and he and Sridhar approached
Sivaji Ganesan to star. Ganesan refused, saying another producer was adapting the story (as
Sri Valli) and paid him an advance to star in it. Rao and Sridhar then considered adapting
The Man in the Iron Mask, the third part of the 1847–1850 novel
The Vicomte of Bragelonne: Ten Years Later by
Alexandre Dumas. Though it had already been adapted in Tamil as
Uthama Puthiran (1940), an unfazed Sridhar decided to remake the film as it had been more than 15 years since release. Ganesan accepted to star in the project. The remake's screenplay was written by Sridhar, who co-produced the film with his partners S. Krishnamoorthy and T. Govindarajan under the banner Venus Pictures. It is the first film to feature Ganesan in dual roles. Sridhar initially wanted
K. Ramnoth to direct this film, but he said he agreed to direct the same subject with
M. G. Ramachandran in lead role, he was replaced by Prakash Rao. When Venus Pictures announced
Uthama Puthiran in a newspaper, the same day Ramachandran announced a film with the same title in the same paper. Ramachandran eventually scrapped his film, but persisted with his plans to make a dual role film and finally made
Nadodi Mannan, and released it several months after
Uthama Puthiran. Cinematography was handled by
A. Vincent, and the editing by N. M. Shankar. "Yaaradi Nee Mohini", the first
rock and roll dance song in Tamil cinema, is picturised on
Hindi cinema dancer
Helen. Ganesan, being trained in classical Indian dance, did not have any difficulty in learning or performing his dance moves. While shooting the song "Unnazhagai Kanniyargal" at
Brindavan Gardens in
Mysore, Vincent needed to capture Padmini and Ganesan – who were far from each other – in the same frame, but was unable to do so in high resolution. He then borrowed a French tourist's lens and fitted it into his own
Paillard-Bolex 16 mm camera, giving a zoom effect and allowing Vincent to shoot as desired. The 16 mm footage was sent to London, where it was blown up to 35 mm. Thus,
Uthama Puthiran became the first Indian film to have the shots with zoom technique. The final length of the film measured . == Soundtrack ==