Menken is lauded as one of the first filmmakers from the New York scene to endow the handheld camera with an elementary freedom, as it swings and sways its way around the scene. This was first apparent in
Visual Variations on Noguchi (1945). Menken made this film while working as a studio assistant to Japanese-American sculptor Isamu Noguchi. Reflecting on the context within which the film was made, Menken shared:I was working on something … for Noguchi, some special effects for
The Seasons, a ballet by
Merce Cunningham with music by
John Cage, and while I was experimenting around, I had the advantage of looking around Isamu's studio with a clear, unobstructed eye. I asked if I might come in and shoot around, and he said yes. I did that. And when he saw that footage, he was entertained and delighted. So was I. It was fun. All art should be fun in a sense and give one a kick.
Visual Variations on Noguchi was Menken's attempt to "capture the flying spirit of movement within these [sculptural] objects". In an effort to express how she felt while looking at Noguchi's sculptures, she began dancing among them, capturing her own movements, affections and rhythmic encounters with the environment. After seeing the film, Stan Brakhage said:
Visual Variation on Noguchi liberated a lot of independent filmmakers from the idea that had been so powerful up to then, that we have to imitate the Hollywood dolly shot, without dollies – that the smooth pan and dolly was the only acceptable thing. Marie's free, swinging, swooping hand-held pans changed all that, for me and for the whole independent filmmaking world. In addition to her treatment of the camera, both Brakhage and Jonas Mekas also celebrated Menken as the ultimate film poet. For Brakhage in particular, Menken "made a translation of poetic possibilities into the language of cinema". This is a historic role that some (including film scholar Melissa Ragona) have argued limits the critical contribution of Menken's practice, reducing it to a means of contextualizing (and bolstering) Brakhage's position in the history of experimental cinema. Indeed, Menken herself responded to Brakhage's determination by reminding him that "There is enough English poetry to read in a lifetime, why bother with attempts at translations from other languages?" But Brakhage is on record as having said, "If there is one single filmmaker that I owe the most to for the crucial development of my own film making, it would be Marie Menken." Rather than identifying Menken's work as a matter of poetic translation, Ragona argues that
Moon Play and
Night Writing in particular explore the painterly possibilities of working with light as a material and celluloid as a medium/canvas. For Ragona, Menken's cinematic works are an attempt to push the limits of painting toward the kinetic. Menken's work was included in the 2021 exhibition
Women in Abstraction at the
Centre Pompidou. ==Filmography==