In October 2007, the
European Court of Justice ruled that the VW law was illegal because of its
protectionist nature. At that time, the
Porsche SE holding company held 30.9% of VW Group shares and there had been speculation that Porsche SE would be interested in buying all shares if the law did not stand in its way. The Court of Justice also prevented the government appointing Volkswagen board members. In 2008, the German government then rewrote the Volkswagen law, attempting to sidestep the ECJ judgment; removing restrictions on share ownership but still requiring an 80% majority for important decisions, so Lower Saxony would still be able to block major business decisions and takeovers.
European Commission regulators took the German government to court again and requested a fine of €31,114 per day backdated to when the law was declared illegal in 2007, plus larger ongoing fines from the date of a second court judgment. In March 2012, the German government insisted that it would defend the Volkswagen Law in court. In October 2013, the EU Court of Justice ruled that the redraft of the Volkswagen law “complied in full” with
Union law, bringing "the matter to a close,” as Chantal Hughes, spokeswoman for EU Internal Markets Commissioner
Michel Barnier said. ==Outcome==