1975 Murder of Shirley Finn Shirley Finn was a Perth
brothel keeper and
nightclub operator who was shot dead in her car around midnight on 23 June 1975 in
South Perth. The murder of Finn has long been rumoured to have resulted from a police conspiracy with political ramifications. The specific circumstances surrounding Finn's death, including her alleged sighting at the canteen bar of the WA Police headquarters in East Perth shortly before her murder, have never been officially disclosed, despite several purported investigations and a
Royal Commission. In 2017, following persistent public interest in the case over the years, a
coroner's inquest was opened to take evidence from witnesses regarding the killing, which sat through 28 days of evidence and heard from some 70 witnesses. The inquest returned an
open finding with Coroner Barry King closing with the announcement that there had been "incompetence" in the police investigation and that there were "too many suspects", while vital evidence had "disappeared", including the murder weapon and the victim's luxury car. The Coroner's report further acknowledged that the "most compelling theory" about why she was killed related to her "[attempts] to
blackmail police about corruption", with the report further providing "it is a curious feature of this analysis that the circumstances of the murder and the existence of the motive appear to be interdependent." No suspects have ever been formally charged in the matter and, as of 2025, the crime remains unsolved.
Deaths in custody The 1987-1991
Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody reported on the underlying social, cultural, and legal issues behind deaths in custody of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Amongst 99 cases investigated by the Commission was the violent death of a 16-year-old Aboriginal boy,
death of John Pat, whilst in the custody of WA Police in
Roebourne, Western Australia in 1983. Commissioner
Elliott Johnston expressed public criticism over the lack of any disciplinary charges against five officers implicated in the violent death of a 16-year-old Aboriginal Boy, finding the circumstances and event of Pat's death "a most unsatisfactory state of affairs". The 2002
Kennedy Royal Commission investigated the February 1988 death of 18-year-old Stephen Wardle, who died whilst in custody in the East Perth lockup. A particularly controversial aspect of the case was that 17 police witnesses declined to give evidence at the Coronial Inquiry "for the reason that their evidence might have had the tendency to incriminate them." The Commission's report noted: In 2002, the
Kennedy Royal Commission commenced to examine aspects of the behaviour and culture of the service. It concluded in 2004, finding that "...the full range of corrupt or criminal conduct from stealing to assaults, perjury, drug dealing and the improper disclosure of confidential information have been examined. [The Western Australian Police Service] has been ineffective in monitoring those events and modifying its procedures to deal with that conduct and to prevent its repetition. The fact that there remain in WAPS a number of officers who participated in this conduct, and who not only refused to admit it, but also uniformly denied it with vehemence, is a matter of concern." In June 2020, Western Australian
Attorney-General,
John Quigley, made comments to SBS News ahead of a
Black Lives Matter rally in Perth, marking "systematic discrimination" against
Indigenous Australians in the state's justice system. Quigley closed by saying that legislative reforms were being planned.
Investigative abuses 2007 Corryn Rayney murder investigation Corryn Rayney was an Australian-Ugandan refugee who was found dead in
Kings Park on 16 August 2007. The circumstances surroundiung Rayney's death remain mysterious with no clear cause of death being identified, though police announced early on that her death was being treated as a murder inquiry. Rayney's husband,
Lloyd Rayney, a prominent barrister specialising in criminal prosecution, was charged with her murder, but was found not guilty by Justice
Brian Martin. In handing down his not guilty verdict, Justice Martin was critical of some police actions, stating that "there were instances of unacceptable conduct by some investigators ranging from inappropriate to reprehensible". He added that he had found "no evidence that lines of inquiry were not properly investigated". Some five years before charges were laid, the Senior Sergeant in charge of the investigation had publicly named
Lloyd Rayney as the force's "only suspect" and the "primary person of interest". At the trial, which extended over three months, the Judge found that "the State case is bereft of any evidence [establishing] a crime scene". He concluded "The case for the State is beset by improbabilities and uncertainties. Crucial evidence is lacking and the absence of evidence tells strongly against the State. Endeavours by the State to fill critical gaps and explain away improbabilities are primarily no more than speculation without foundation in the evidence." An April 2014 report of the Western Australian
Corruption and Crime Commission (CCC) cleared two police officers of any serious misconduct in the
Rayney murder investigation. Their behaviour in threatening a female lawyer had been described as ranging from "inappropriate to reprehensible" by the trial judge. A second matter reviewed by the CCC related to "attempts by a third officer to encourage an independent pathologist involved in the case to change a report to better fit police evidence. That officer was found to have acted unreasonably." In September 2014, lawyer and former State Governor, Malcolm McCusker, supported calls for an independent review, and also a CCC investigation of "claims that police manufactured evidence to incriminate ... Lloyd Rayney". As of 2017, the senior investigating officer in the Rayney murder case continued to regard Lloyd Rayney as "the prime and only suspect", despite Lloyd Rayney's comprehensive exoneration by the courts. A
defamation action brought by Lloyd Rayney resulted in a record compensation award of over $2.6 million and legal costs of over $10 million. On 21 April 2020, Lloyd Rayney was struck off by Legal Practice Board. Later the same year, Lloyd Rayney sued one of the lead forensic investigators on the case for allegedly making defamatory comments at a seminar at
Curtin University in 2014. Lloyd Rayney was awarded in damages.
Wrongful prosecutions Justice Martin's criticism of the Corryn Rayney investigation followed the exposure of a number of notorious cases of wrongful prosecution by Western Australia Police, including those of
John Button,
Darryl Beamish,
the Mickelberg brothers and
Andrew Mallard, resulting in reversal of long-standing convictions and large compensation payouts by the
Western Australian Government. In the case of Mallard, who spent 12 years in prison after an unjust conviction, a former WA Police Assistant Commissioner concluded "Mallard is a very clear example of how police and prosecutorial misconduct can lead to a wrongful conviction and a miscarriage of justice ... It is also another clear example of the difficulties in holding people to account."
Scott Austic A clemency petition drafted by the eminent barrister
Malcolm McCusker, and lodged with the Western Australian Attorney-General in 2012, alleged that "key evidence was planted, withheld and misrepresented" in police investigations leading to a 2009 murder trial in which
Scott Douglas Austic was found guilty and sentenced to a minimum 25-year jail term. After two successive Attorneys-General declined to act on the petition, a fresh petition for clemency was lodged in March 2018 with Attorney-General
John Quigley, who also proposed legislation to allow people convicted of crimes to apply directly to the Court of Appeal. Quigley, formerly an honorary life member of the
Police Union of Western Australia, subsequently became a fierce critic of the WA Police culture and hierarchy. After spending over a decade in jail, in May 2020, Austic won an appeal against his conviction, and was acquitted at a retrial in November 2020. and is seeking compensation from the State of Western Australia. Reports by the state's Corruption and Crime Commission in 2013 and 2023 "formed no opinion of misconduct among police or prosecutors" involved in the investigation or prosecution of Austic, and said "limitations in evidence collected by police meant it was not possible to determine issues around evidence being planted." Austic asked the Western Australian Government for in compensation but, in May 2023, was given an
ex-gratia payment of , following "comprehensive legal advice". Police Commissioner
Karl O'Callaghan apologised for the investigative failure, but disclosed the three officers "had not accepted blame and would now face an internal disciplinary process".
Taser misuse incidents Robert Cunningham and Catherin Atoms In November 2008, Robert Cunningham, an Associate Law Professor, and his wife Catherine Atoms, were
tasered by WA Police officers during an arrest following an incident outside the Esplanade Hotel in Fremantle. Cunningham and Atoms were both taken into custody and charged with Obstructing a Public Officer. In 2010, charges against both Cunningham and Atoms were dismissed after a Magistrate described evidence given by one of the arresting police officers as "extremely evasive", "imprecise" and "unconvincing". Between 2008 and 2015, Cunningham repeatedly requested that the matter be investigated to no success. In 2016, the couple launched civil proceedings against the State of Western Australia and the three WA Police officers involved. In December 2016, a District Court Judge, Felicity Davis, awarded over in damages over the incident.
Taser "initiation rituals" In December 2010, two senior WA Police officers, a 53-year-old Sergeant and 45-year-old Senior Constable, were dismissed for lying to investigators during an internal inquiry into the misuse of
tasers at
Rockingham Police Station. Police Internal Affairs investigators found that, between October 2008 and May 2010, on a number of occasions, the Sergeant and Senior Constable misused tasers against other members of staff, including females, during bizarre initiation and farewell ceremonies to the station. Police Commissioner Karl O'Callaghan noted that the primary reason for the officers' dismissal was that the Sergeant and Senior Constable had repeatedly lied to investigators during the inquiry, stating "the final straw in this whole sorry saga was that neither of the two officers investigated told the truth to internal investigators when they were first required to ... they continued to deny the allegations and offered improbable explanations for their behaviour", and that one of the officers had to be interviewed six times in order to get a full and proper account of the incident. In April 2012, the CCC made several misconduct findings, recommended charges, and said police used "undue and excessive" force. In April 2013, it was reported that two senior officers were to be tried on criminal charges over the incident, though in a January 2014 hearing, the two officers were fined and given suspended jail terms for unlawful assault. On 6 September 2008, Spratt suffered a dislocated shoulder, fractured ribs, and a collapsed lung in prison following a "cell extraction" wherein he was tasered eleven times by Emergency Support Group officers from the Department of Corrective Services. The CCC later found that seven out of the 11 taser deployments were "reasonable", while no findings were made to the other four due to insufficient evidence. Spratt later pleaded guilty to the charge of Obstructing Police and was jailed for two months. The December 2019 incidents came after a series of disturbing clashes with police, which the WA Police Union expressed concern in regards to Spratt's aggressive behaviour, noting that "Spratt's aggressive behaviour has escalated to the point that numerous police officers and medical staff have allegedly been assaulted by him in separate incidents". In 2019, at the age of 50, Spratt took his own life. In 2019, Keenan was found guilty of two counts of Common Assault against the motorist and received an eight month suspended prison sentence. Keenan was also ordered to pay a fine of and court costs of almost .
Charges brought against serving police officers "Clothes-line" attack on motorbike riders On 27 November 2010, an off-duty Senior Constable in WA Police's
Specialist Enforcement and Operations Team, Matthew Gerard Owen Pow, was charged with two counts of
committing an act causing danger or bodily harm and two counts of
assault causing bodily harm, after allegedly tying a rope across a Karawara path, known to be used by motorbike riders at night. Two boys, aged 15 and 16, sustained superficial injuries after falling off their motorcycles, later claiming Pow tied the rope across the path. Pow appeared before Perth Magistrates Court on 4 January 2011. Pow's defence argued that insufficient evidence existed for his conviction as the rope alleged to have been used was never located. On 8 March 2012, a jury acquitted Pow, finding him not guilty.
Police officer twice convicted of assault In February 2019, ABC news reported that WA Police Senior Constable, Nathan Robert Trenberth, was filmed repeatedly punching a 20-year-old man in the head during the
Sky Show celebrations. The presiding Magistrate described his use of force as "unreasonable" and convicted the officer of assault and fined him . Trenberth had a second conviction for assault in relation to an arrest of a man at a 2006 Australia Day fireworks display. ==See also==