Krenchicki was the seventh player chosen overall by the
Baltimore Orioles in the secondary phase of the January
1976 Major League Baseball draft. Krenchicki was sent to the
Cincinnati Reds on
February 15, 1982 to complete a transaction from five days prior in which the
Orioles had acquired
Paul Moskau. That season, he backed up
Johnny Bench at third base for the Reds, batting .283. Krenchicki was traded to the
Detroit Tigers for
Pat Underwood on
June 30, 1983. His contract was sold back to the Reds just under five months later on
November 21. Over the next two seasons, Krenchicki returned to being the Reds backup at third base, behind
Nick Esasky in and
Buddy Bell in . He was traded to the
Montreal Expos the following offseason, and in he played mostly at first base for the Expos, backing up
Andrés Galarraga. After becoming a free agent at the end of the season, Krenchicki did not play in the majors again. ==Post-MLB==