Original version American magazine
Billboard wrote that "We Are Family" has "an upbeat, catchy melody" and "heavy bass, funky guitar and pulsating percussion."
Cash Box said that the song has "caressing, exuberant lead vocals backed by Sister Sledge's infectious harmony vocals." Richard Smith from
Melody Maker commented, "Everybody from the women's movement to troupes of cheerleaders claimed the mighty "We Are Family" as their own anthem, but it's always had a special place in the hearts of gay men. Appropriation or intention? Chic were quite canny – it was New York's gay clubs that had broken them and songs like this were a way of paying back the debt."
1993 remix In his weekly UK chart commentary,
James Masterton wrote, "Your eyes do not deceive you. At a time when the 1970s are suddenly hip again, one of the best
soul disco records ever made return in a new set of mixes for 1993."
Paul Lester from
Melody Maker felt it's "perfunctorily remixed", adding, "It remains the last word in identikit-robot-girls-sing-gospel-tinged-melodies-over-machine-beats pop and proves that rock crits have always had guilty consciences about the records they (claim to) like." Alan Jones from
Music Week stated that the song "gets a new treatment from the Sure Is Pure dream team. The result, while less distinctive than the original with much of
Chic's sterling instrumental work suppressed, is a hot and contemporary
garage track." Another
Music Week editor, Andy Beevers, named it Pick of the Week in the category of Dance, adding, "This most enduring and endearing of club classics should make the
Top 40 for the third time thanks to a wonderful and suitably reverential remix by Sure Is Pure." == Music video ==