Beloved in Pittsburgh for his style of play and affable manner, Stargell hit seven of the 18 balls ever hit over
Forbes Field's 86-foot-high right-field stands and several of the upper-tier home runs at its successor,
Three Rivers Stadium. Though he became quickly known as Willie Stargell, his autograph suggests that he preferred his given name, Wilver. Biographer Frank Garland relates that Stargell's family and friends called him Wilver and that Dodgers broadcaster
Vin Scully also made a point of using Stargell's given name. Scully said that because he used the name Wilver, he became Stargell's mother's favorite broadcaster. He made his first of seven trips to the
All-Star Game that year. He returned to the All-Star Game the next two seasons, recording over 100
runs batted in (RBIs) in both years, and finishing respectively 14th and 15th in
MVP voting. He won the first of the three
NL Player of the Month awards of his career in June 1965 (.330, 10 HRs, 35 RBIs). Frequent offseason conditioning problems came to a head in 1967, when Stargell showed up to spring training at a weight of 235 pounds. The team mandated that he diet to get down to a weight of 215 pounds. His batting average dropped more than 40 points that season from .315 in 1966 to .271 in 1967; his home run total was reduced from 33 in 1966 to 20 in 1967. The team had a personal trainer work with Stargell before the 1968 season to get him in the best shape of his career, but Stargell had a poor season and manager
Larry Shepard criticized Stargell's physique as too muscular. He finished out the decade with a strong performance in 1969 (.307, 29 HRs, 92 RBIs), and finished 21st in MVP voting.
1970s Stargell enjoyed another fine season in
1970, batting .264 with 31 home runs and 85 RBIs and finishing 15th in MVP voting. On August 1 of that year, Stargell collected five extra-base hits—three doubles and two home runs—in the Pirates' 20–10 victory over the
Atlanta Braves at
Fulton County Stadium. He became the third player, after
Lou Boudreau in and
Joe Adcock in , to collect five extra-base hits in one game. The game was a Saturday Game of the Week on network television, and ironically the trivia question during the broadcast was "Who are the two players with five extra-base hits in one game?" Stargell became the third in that very game. In the same game, teammate
Bob Robertson also collected five hits, including a home run; not until
Andrew McCutchen and
Garrett Jones in would two Pirates collect five hits in the same game. The 1970 Pirates won the
National League East title for their first postseason berth since winning the
1960 World Series. They were swept in
that year's NLCS by the
Cincinnati Reds, but not before Stargell collected six hits in 12 at-bats, the most hits by either team in this series. Stargell's career moved to another level in
1971. At age 31, he won the first of his two home-run titles in 1971; his 48 edged out
Hank Aaron's 47 on the final week of the season and, to date, trail only
Ralph Kiner's 54 and 51 in and , respectively, for most by a Pirate in one season. He won the final two NL Player of the Month awards of his career in April (.347, 11 HR, 27 RBIs) and in June (.333, 11 HR, 36 RBIs); yet he did not win the MVP award, finishing second to
Joe Torre. Also in April, Stargell hit 3 home runs in a game twice, on April 10 at Atlanta and on April 21 at home. In seven of the next nine seasons, Stargell finished in the top 10 in MVP voting, as his career moved onto a Hall of Fame track. He was a member of the Pirates'
World Championship team, the Pirates defeating the
Baltimore Orioles in seven games. The Pirates lost the first two games of that series, which Stargell said that media began referring to as "the St. Valentine's Day Massacre" before Pittsburgh's comeback. Stargell continued to post excellent numbers in
1972 (.293, 33, 112) finishing third in MVP voting behind
Johnny Bench and
Billy Williams. In
1973, Stargell achieved the rare feat of simultaneously leading the league in both doubles and homers. Stargell had more than 40 of each; he was the first player to chalk up this 40-40 accomplishment since
Hank Greenberg in
1940; other players have done so since (notably
Albert Belle, the only 50-50 player). Stargell won his second home-run title that year, edging out three Atlanta Braves:
Davey Johnson's 43,
Darrell Evans' 41 and Aaron's 40. He also led the league in runs batted in and
slugging percentage. For the third year in a row, he was narrowly edged out of the MVP award. Beginning in
1975, after years of experimenting at the position, Stargell moved permanently to first base. He never played another game in the outfield. In
1977, Stargell hit his 400th career home run on June 29 against the
St. Louis Cardinals. Stargell originated the practice of giving his teammates embroidered "Stargell stars" for their caps after a nice play or a good game. The practice began during the turbulent 1978 season, when the Pirates came from fourth place and 11.5 games behind in mid-August, to challenge the first-place Philadelphia Phillies for the division title. The season was scheduled to end in a dramatic, four-game showdown against the Phillies in Pittsburgh, in which the Pirates had to win all four games to claim the title. Following a Pirate sweep of the Friday-night
double-header, Stargell belted a
grand slam in the bottom of the first inning of the season's penultimate game to give the Pirates an early 4–1 lead, although the Pirates relinquished that lead later in the game and fell two runs short after a four-run rally in the bottom of the ninth inning, thus eliminating themselves from contention for the pennant. Stargell called that 1978 team his favorite team ever, and predicted that the Pirates would win the World Series the following year. The Pirates did win the World Series in 1979, in a similar style as they had ended the 1978 season: from last place in the NL East at the end of April, the Pirates clawed their way into a first-place battle with the
Montreal Expos during the latter half of the season. They excited fans with numerous come-from-behind victories along the way (many during their final at-bat) to claim the division pennant on the last day of the season. At his urging as captain, the team adopted the
Sister Sledge hit song "
We Are Family" as the team anthem. Then, his play on the field inspired his teammates and earned him the MVP awards in both the NLCS and the World Series. Stargell capped off the year by hitting a dramatic home run in Baltimore during the late innings of a close
Game 7 to seal a Pirates' championship. The home run was his third of the series and, coincidentally, credited Stargell with the winning runs in both Game 7s of the two postseason meetings between the Pirates and the Orioles (
1971 and 1979). The 1979 World Series victory also made the Pirates the only franchise in baseball history to twice recover from a three-games-to-one deficit and win a World Series (previously they had done so in
1925 against the
Washington Senators). For the series, Stargell went 12-for-30; along with his three home runs, he also recorded four doubles for 25 total bases, which remains tied as a World Series record,
Reggie Jackson having set it in the
1977 World Series, and his seven extra-base hits (three HRs and four doubles) in the 1979 World Series also set a record. In addition to his NLCS and
World Series MVP awards, Stargell finally took home the elusive
MVP award (as co-winner along with St. Louis'
Keith Hernandez) at the age of 39. Stargell is the only player to have won all three MVP trophies in a single year. He was also named the
Associated Press Athlete of the Year and
The Sporting News Sportsman of the Year. He shared the
Sports Illustrated magazine's "
Sportsmen of the Year" award with
NFL quarterback Terry Bradshaw, who also played at Three Rivers Stadium, for the
Pittsburgh Steelers. Pirates manager
Chuck Tanner said of Stargell, "Having him on your ball club is like having a diamond ring on your finger." Teammate
Al Oliver once said, "If he asked us to jump off the
Fort Pitt Bridge, we would ask him what kind of dive he wanted. That's how much respect we have for the man."
1980s in 1980 Stargell played until 1982, but he never appeared in more than 74 games after 1979. He retired with 475 home runs despite playing much of his career at
Forbes Field, whose center field distance was . Hall of Famer
Roberto Clemente estimated, perhaps generously, that Stargell hit 400 fly balls to the warning track in left and center fields during his eight seasons in the park. The short fence in right field ( to the foul pole) at Forbes Field was guarded by a screen more than high which ran from the right-field line to the mark in right center. Three Rivers Stadium, a neutral hitter's park, boosted Stargell's power numbers. The Pirates moved into Three Rivers in mid-1970, and he hit 310 of his 475 career home runs from 1970 until his retirement, despite turning 30 in 1970. Stargell's two home run titles came in his first three years at Three Rivers. Stargell's last game was on October 3, 1982, at
Three Rivers Stadium against the
Montreal Expos. Batting leadoff, he hit a single off
Steve Rogers. He was then pinch run by
Doug Frobel and subsequently was replaced by
Richie Hebner at first base.
Long home runs At one time, Stargell held the record for the longest home run in nearly half of the NL parks. On August 5, 1969, Stargell hit a home run off
Alan Foster that left the stadium and measured 507 feet, the longest home run hit at
Dodger Stadium. He hit a second home run out of Dodger Stadium on May 8, 1973, against
Andy Messersmith, measured at . Dodger Hall of Famer
Don Sutton said of Stargell, "I never saw anything like it. He doesn't just hit pitchers, he takes away their dignity." Only six other home runs have been hit out of Dodger Stadium (2 in the 2025 postseason). On June 25, 1971, Stargell hit the longest home run in
Veterans Stadium history during a 14–4 Pirates win over the Philadelphia Phillies. The shot came in the second inning and chased starting pitcher
Jim Bunning out of the game. The spot where the ball landed was eventually marked with a yellow star with a black "S" inside a white circle until Stargell's 2001 death, when the white circle was painted black. The star remained in place until the stadium's 2004 demolition. In 1978, against
Wayne Twitchell of the Montreal Expos, Stargell hit the only fair ball to reach the club deck of
Olympic Stadium. The seat where the ball landed (the home run was measured at ) was replaced with a yellow seat, while the other seats in the upper deck are red. Upon the Expos departure in 2004, the seat was removed and sent to the
Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame.
Bob Prince, the colorful longtime Pirate radio announcer, would greet a Stargell home run with the phrase "Chicken on the Hill". This referred to Stargell's ownership of a chicken restaurant in Pittsburgh's
Hill District. For a time, whenever he homered, Stargell's restaurant would give away free chicken to all patrons present in the restaurant at the time of the home run, in a promotion dubbed "Chicken on the Hill with Will". Prince himself once promised free chicken to listeners if Stargell hit a home run; Stargell did homer and Prince picked up a $400 bill at the restaurant. ==Career statistics==