Welcome to the Dance received generally mixed reviews from music critics, many of whom praised the band for their courage to breakaway from their
pop rock sounds on previous releases but found the material uneven. Entertainment magazine
Mix1 remarked that the band entered "a new musical dimension with
Welcome to the Dance. The title is quite programmatic to understand [...] Mainly up-tempo-numbers, peppered with elaborate beats and incredible effects. Pop meets electro, R&B and soul. New, fresh, surprising and sometimes almost experimental. Definitely international." Astrid Weist, editor for
MusicHeadQuarter, complimented No Angels for their decision to revamp their sound and gave the album eight stars out of ten, declaring it "a surprising album in several aspects." Generally satisfied with the inclusion of contemporary dancefloor tracks and familiar sounding ballads, she summed the album a "rather convincing musical mixture." Lifestyle magazine
In Touch felt that "although the 14 songs sound pop in the usual manner, new impulses come from driving beats that lead away from the ballad mentality of past years. Despite the new sound, the four ladies sound more mature, mature and yes, even more diverse than before. It seems they have found themselves and are now where they've always wanted to go with their songs."
CDStarts.de writer Tanja Kraus gave the album five out of ten stars and complimented its international niveau and self-penned, well-produced pop character. and although they were persuaded that the band had not made the most out of it, they complimented No Angels for their songwriting and the corresponding results which they compared to a "whiff of
Rihanna". In his consumer guide for
LetMeEntertainYou.de, Michael Bauer also rated the album one star out of five, summing it "a dance towards career ending." He felt that
Welcome to the Dance was "nothing but monotonous club stamping", and dismissed the heavy usage of effects on the voices and beats. ==Release and performance==